masthead.jpg

switchconcepts.com, U3dpdGNo-a25, DIRECT rubiconproject.com, 14766, RESELLER pubmatic.com, 30666, RESELLER, 5d62403b186f2ace appnexus.com, 1117, RESELLER thetradedesk.com, switchconcepts, RESELLER taboola.com, switchconceptopenrtb, RESELLER bidswitch.com, switchconcepts, RESELLER contextweb.com, 560031, RESELLER amazon-adsystem.com, 3160, RESELLER crimtan.com, switch, RESELLER quantcast.com, switchconcepts , RESELLER rhythmone.com, 1934627955, RESELLER ssphwy.com, switchconcepts, RESELLER emxdgt.com, 59, RESELLER appnexus.com, 1356, RESELLER sovrn.com, 96786, RESELLER, fafdf38b16bf6b2b indexexchange.com, 180008, RESELLER nativeads.com, 52853, RESELLER theagency.com, 1058, RESELLER google.com, pub-3515913239267445, DIRECT, f08c47fec0942fa0
August 20, 2008

One of the things I never quite grasped was the mocking Coach Wannstedt came in for at the end of his first year back at Pitt. The debacle that was the Backyard Brawl that year had a sideline interview at the half asking what Pitt needed to do to get back in the game. “Get faster,” was Wannstedt’s response.

For some reason, many on the outside saw this as an indication of Wannstedt’s overall cluelessness about the game. I think most Pitt fans recognized that Wannstedt was not talking about the game in particular at that point. The game, that was already out of hand — and with H.B. Blades injured — not going to get better. What he was talking about was the program and team — but specifically the defense — needed a lot more speed.

Whether it was to contend with the proliferating spread offense. Or just the way college football was becoming. Oddly, within a year of that statement there began the whole meme about the speed in the SEC and the plodding, slow athletes in the Big 11. Conflicting styles and speed was winning nearly every argument.

Whether it was Wannstedt recognizing the trend or just because his defensive philosophy has always been about generating speed on defense it probably doesn’t matter. Pitt’s defense was anything but in the first couple years.

Last year Pitt began showing it, but the lack of depth and execution was glaring. Especially the mindset and execution. The Navy game was the worst demonstration of the problems with the execution and a defensive braintrust that just could not seem to understand where to adjust against Navy’s triple option.

The theory that Wannstedt effectively took control of the defense from DC Paul Rhoads after the Navy game is still just that. It’s an attractive one. Don’t get me wrong. As a long-time member of the anti-Rhoads base, I find it very appealing and believable. It’s unlikely, however, that we’ll ever know. And really, all that matters is that Rhoads is gone.

Keep in mind, however, that 10 days later, Pitt still gave up over 350 yards in offense. 3 Cinci turnovers in the 4th quarter were the reason Pitt was able to take the lead and hold on to the win. The point being, the defense remained inconsistent and prone to giving up big plays and yardage even if it was statistically strong.

I was thinking about the speed on defense for the past week after this article on “tweeners” and moving kids one spot back on defense.

And those “tweeners” — like safety Elijah Fields, who is 6 feet 2, 225 pounds and runs the 40-yard dash in less than 4.5 seconds, or defensive end Jabaal Sheard, who is 6 feet 4, 250 pounds and runs the 40 in about 4.7 seconds, are the type of players every defensive coach covets.

“Offenses have gotten smart, and they are putting more skill-position players out there and making you cover them all,” Bennett said. “It has completely changed the way we have to recruit.

“Now, we’ve got to find those what I call hybrid players to play linebacker — kids who are smart and who are fast and maybe played other positions in high school.”

Bennett said the spread offense is the “passing version of the wishbone” because the concepts are pretty much the same: The offense spreads the defense out and reacts to where the numbers favor the offense. If there are five defensive players in the box, the offense will likely run the ball. If the defense decides to put a sixth or seventh player into the box, the offense will react with a pass.

The concept of putting “hybrid” players on the defensive side of the ball is not new, especially not to Pitt coach Dave Wannstedt, who has been building defenses this way for nearly his entire career.

It’s all about creating exploitable mismatches whether on the offensive or defensive side of the ball.

As for Elijah Fields, specifically, he has an incredible opportunity before him. The NFL has been evolving in its own way. Fields is in a system, paired with his own ability that will get him to the pros. Especially as a safety in today’s game.

The safety position is evolving to match increasingly complex playbooks, personnel packages and presnap adjustments. Versatility—not size—is the key. Today’s top safeties (think Ed Reed and Bob Sanders) have to match up with freakishly athletic tight ends and barracuda-quick slot receivers while still providing run support and zapping receivers on crossing routes.

Coaches can mask some of the deficiencies of a pass-challenged safety with Cover 2 schemes, but that pulls an enforcer off the line of scrimmage. The Cover 3 is an alternative, but not every DB is comfortable in zone, where spacing and discipline require constant vigilance. Plus, spread sets, motion, no-huddle and playaction still can create (or mimic) scenarios that force a safety to match up one-on-one with a slot receiver or downfield burner. And with refs throwing illegal-contact flags more than ever, there’s no margin for error.

He seems to be catching on the big picture of his future. I hope he gets how close it actually is.





That was a very sound and intellectally honest thesis made. I do however want to point out that Rhoades had had success before Wanny and during Wanny. The lack of good athletest was the common factor during Rhoades decline on defense. It seems to me only people wishing for Rhoades to be the problem founded that rumor. I don’t remember any inside sources saying Dave took over. In fact…I think most people blamed Dave if they did not blame Rhoades.

Again, I felt your post was honest and insightful. I just don’t see Rhoades as being responsible for bad athletes and slow 40’s.

Comment by Pittisforreal 08.20.08 @ 2:23 pm

Wasn’t the “run faster” comment made in 2005, when the halftime score was out of hand in WVU?? If I recall correctly, 2006 BYB had Pitt leading at halftime…

Comment by Wanstache 08.20.08 @ 2:40 pm

no sixth year for cook. that’s too bad. best of luck to mr. cook in the future.

Comment by Omar 08.20.08 @ 2:48 pm

The Cook ruling is bullshit. Mark linked to the Post-Gazette story in the free Mike Cook thread. Best of luck to Mike!

Comment by maz. 08.20.08 @ 3:01 pm

I’m seeing some familiar comments on Paul Rhoades’ defense in the local papers here in Mobile, AL. A week ago Sunday, the headline on the sports page talked about the Auburn defense’s poor tackling. The article spoke of poor open field tackling and lax fundamentals on the part of the defense in Auburn’s first scrimmage.

see: link to al.com

Comment by KeithS 08.20.08 @ 3:26 pm

The run faster comment was at Mountaineer Field, which would make it 2005

Comment by Jamie H 08.20.08 @ 4:19 pm

There is no way that Rhoades ran the D after the Navy Game. He only succeeded if the other team made a mistake and that was what his defensive scheme was built around.
I don’t want to hear about the lack of talent. Many teams have done much better with less talent.
Pitt has several players in the NFL now that were here during Rhoade’s tenure on the defensive side of the ball. Many other college teams can’t say that.
He ran the read and react D or as I like to call it the Sit and Wait D. It does not work well against the run. We have seen that several times over the years. There are a few running backs in the NFL that should cut Rhoades a check or two as repayment for making them look better then they really are.

Comment by Tony In Harrisburg 08.20.08 @ 4:33 pm

Mike Cook just got denied a 6th year of eligibility by the NCAA. By their rules, you are only eligible for a medical redshirt if you play 30% of your team’s games and although Cook only played in 11 out of our 37 games, our 6 postseason games count as only one for the redshirt, meaning he played in 11/32 of our games. Definitely a tough loss but the way I see it, Gilbert Brown was our starting SF in all our late-year victories, for the Big East Tournament, and gives us a huge athletic boost in the starting lineup. While I wish the best for Mike, I think this now gives the Panthers an opportunity to really look forward and plan for this season.

Comment by merlin 08.20.08 @ 4:41 pm

KeithS,

Thanks for pointing out what many of us knew to be the case with any P Rhoades D.

A lowlight from the article below.

Top tailback Brad Lester said he carried the ball only a handful of times, with most of the reps going to Smith. He said the offense seemed farther ahead of the defense than usual this time of year.

“We’ve never scored a lot of points on the defense, especially in the first scrimmage,” Lester said. “It seemed like we almost did what we wanted to do on offense. Pretty much the defense couldn’t stop us.”

Get used to it Tiger fans, just get used to it.

Comment by Tony In Harrisburg 08.20.08 @ 4:41 pm

The Cook deal is a bummer. If their logic is that Cook played in more than 30 percent of Pitt’s regular season games — fine — you can’t dispute that. But did it really take them five months to divide 11 by 31? Here’s wishing him the best of luck!

Comment by Dave in Orlando 08.20.08 @ 5:13 pm

RE: Rhodes–I seem to recall discussion that Rhodes was initially, at least, held over from the Harris staff because of the size and length of his remaining contract and that Pitt felt it couldn’t aford the buyout on top of DW’s new contract. Anyone else recall anything similar?

Comment by pitt1972 08.20.08 @ 5:44 pm

Rhoades was forced on DW due to contract considerations. That sounds about right. I don’t think that’s the spin they put on it but that’s how it looked to me.

Comment by Tony In Harrisburg 08.20.08 @ 6:14 pm

I think Coach W “encouraged” Coach Rhodes to seek employment elsewhere after the Navy game.

Comment by HbgFrank 08.20.08 @ 9:24 pm

link to i22.tinypic.com

If WVU runs all over Auburn, i think that’ll answer the question as to who was responsible for 13-9.

Comment by Stuart 08.20.08 @ 11:20 pm

More good information:

‘Players and coaches say there won’t be any dramatic changes between Muschamp and Rhoads. Rhoads has tweaked some of the terminology and appears to be using fewer 3-4 sets. Also, his philosophy in the secondary doesn’t seem as aggressive as Muschamp’s.

“Coach Muschamp was helping me become excellent in the man-to-man press,” said cornerback Walt McFadden. “Coach Rhoads taught me how to play off. I can guard receivers a lot better now just by backpedaling and using the ‘scooch’ technique.”‘

Comment by Stuart 08.20.08 @ 11:28 pm

Finally, i’m tired of hearing how we had the “5th best” defense last year. We didn’t. We had the 42nd best defense. I’m with coach bennet on this, the ONLY thing that matters is scoring defense – not some stupid “yards per game.” And we gave up 24 points a game. That has to improve. To be in the top ten we have to hold people to less than 17 or 18 a game.

Comment by Stuart 08.20.08 @ 11:39 pm

I lied…this is the video referred to above…

link to youtube.com

and then go to about 7.30 in this one…

link to youtube.com

He who laughs last…

Comment by Stuart 08.20.08 @ 11:57 pm

Stuart – of all the things about that evening of the 13-9 game – DW’s stating that ‘We ran faster” really stuck in my mind. But, his next statement was even more telling…. “and we’ll get faster…” He has recruited the best speed and the best athletes for PITT that I can remember in a long time.

Interesting segue – if Murray stays out due to his knee, watch Austin Ransom as his replacement – an example of what we are talking about here… tough and fast kid on the field.

Comment by Reed 08.21.08 @ 5:28 am

Powered by WordPress © PittBlather.com

Site Meter