masthead.jpg

August 7, 2014

   As a final Part Four of our preseason review let’s look at how the coaching staff has done so far and what we can expect from those paid by the PITT administration to both prepare the team for competition and then guide it to a winning season.   This is an area of the program that elicits the strongest opinions, both pro and con, from us PITT fans and rightly so.  With our four year track record from 2010 through to the 2014 season, we have been pulled through the wringer with the trials and tribulations of not only the football coaching personalities and their actions but also by some debatable decisions made by the PITT administration.

   I don’t really want to revisit the head coaching hires and departures over the past five years in this article; nor do I want to parse the Athletic Director and the Chancellor’s decision making over that time period.  We all know what a cluster it has been and I’m not sure it has much to do with the current football team and the upcoming season at this point.  That said, we need to focus on the Head Coach and discuss what strength of program Chryst inherited as a new hire and how he has progressed from that point until this training camp.

   My personal opinion is that Paul Chryst has done an admirable job under the circumstances he walked into, with his eyes wide open, at PITT.  If you look back at a lot of D1 new head coaching hire’s first two years won and loss record you’ll see a dip from the previous seasons in a lot of instances.  Chryst has avoided that after inheriting a 6-7 team and then having 6-7 and 7-6 seasons, while at the same time strengthening the program from the inside out.  Perhaps it is small blessings but at least we didn’t slide backward in that transition to Chryst as HC.  He has approached this PITT job with a clear intent to recruit players he wants in his systems while also making sure that he gets kids who can succeed academically and take direction well.

  His recruiting approach has either been embraced by PITT fans or subject to some derision by them because he isn’t landing multiple 4* and 5* recruits.  I’d like to be a fly on the wall at some of the staff meetings during recruiting season as I’m just not sure how successful they themselves consider these last two recruiting classes.  On one hand a positive proof could be in the fact that so many redshirt and true freshman played a large amount of time last year.  I can’t remember any other season where our two deep line up was so very young.  I’d hazard to guess that we’ll see the same thing happen this season with the redshirted freshman and the incoming true freshman class.  On the other hand all those kids might have been just forced to play because of a general lack of talent across the roster.

   Playing that much youth in 2012 was a risk that many rookie 1st year HCs wouldn’t take.  Chryst has a long view and has changed the existing roster coming out of the 2011 season pretty dramatically over the past two years.  We saw many 5th year seniors and other more junior players who were moved on, transferred, or quit football.  From the 2013 scholarship roster Crockett, Banks, Giubilato, Felder, Christian, Ifill, and Shane Johnson didn’t return this year.  After the 2012 season Doakes, Chapman, Mason,  Shell, the Davis twins, Rippy, Carswell, Eric Smith, Carrozzini, S. Williams, Frimpong, Ryles and Terrell Jackson left the program.

   That is at least 21 players (if my memory serves) and 21 scholarships Chryst had to use for more  of his own recruits.  That is also a 25% turnover generated by circumstances aside from the normal end of career attrition.  You can assume that many of those recruited in place of the departed will get decent PT this year, especially when it happened last season as Chryst fielded 19 FR and true SO kids who were his recruits on the two deep listing.  That folks is a young ass team and exactly how Chryst is building for the 2015 season and beyond.

   On the flip side we have gotten some pretty good transfers in wanting to finish their college careers with Chryst as their head coach.  Savage was a great addition, Reggie Mitchell, Jameel Poteat, who will be available in 2015, are going to play for us also. On a separate issue we now have a much stronger walk-on program then in the past with 21 roster spots being filled this season with kids who didn’t have scholarships but wanted to be at PITT anyway.  Most came onboard in 2012 and sat out a 2013 as a redshirt year.  In the past Chryst and the Wisconsin Staff made great use of walk-ons in their program and Chryst is doing the same now at PITT.  Again, I anticipate Chryst being here for a good length of time and he’s building his program and his team(s) with that in mind.

   All that aside, where the rubber meets the road for any HC is in two areas.  How he’s running the program and how he’s winning football games.  The former is well in hand and I think at this point the jury is still out on the latter.  Above we discussed his actual W-L record, but the question of ‘how’ he’s winning, or losing, games is still unanswered.  We have see some pretty glaring in-game decisions that backfired on him, what comes to mind first is his clock management in some losses.  But there are a whole slew of variables that go into what the outcome of a game is going to be.

   What very good HCs do is hire a staff they trust to execute the HC’s overarching gameplan. They do not get bogged down in the preparation of the actual playcalling or schematic details and they let their Coordinators handle the ‘trickle down’ directions to their respective position coaches.  I have no idea if this is actually how Chryst runs his ship or not, but I suspect it is with perhaps more hands-on work with House on the defensive side.  He does have the final say on the two deep personnel, chip in with play calls every so often and personally makes the in-game FG or conversion try decisions as most HCs do.

   I do know that Chryst is a stickler for keeping things simple in both preparation and execution and he is calm at almost all times and situations… although I and the PITT fans have seen him explode a few times. What I’m saying is that I’m not knowledgable enough about the working relations between Chryst and his staff to know whether is it working that well or not.  It is safe to say though that some of his hires, mostly acquaintances and friends from his Wisconsin days have been headscratchers for us fans with DC  House in particular.

   OK, now I’ll throw in my two cents about the current supporting staff and their works so far then open the floor for comments and discussion.

Here is our current football coaching staff makeup:

Paul Chryst – Head Coach & Quarterbacks
Joe Rudolph – Assistant Head Coach/Off. Coordinator/Tight Ends
Matt House – Defensive Coordinator/Linebackers
Inoke Breckterfield – Defensive Tackles
Troy Douglas – Secondary
Chris Haering – Special Teams Coordinator/Outside Linebackers
Jim Hueber – Offensive Line
Greg Lewis – Wide Receivers
John Palermo – Defensive Ends
John Settle – Running Backs
Ross Kolodziej – Head Strength and Conditioning Coach

   In my opinion there are three crucial areas that need to be examined and improved on with the staff. First and certainly foremost is Matt House as our Defensive Coordinator. It’s safe to say that no PITT fan was overwhelmed by the defense’s performance last year or by the coaching job House did with his defensive personnel. We read about the defense in the last article and I don’t want to repeat it here. Suffice to say that if Coach House doesn’t markedly improve with a full year as DC under his belt we’ll be in trouble.  I’m not as upset as a lot of fans are that he was chosen by Chryst for the job, I’m actually pretty OK with that, but the time is now to reverse the decline trend in our scoring defense.

   In 2011 with Graham we gave up 22.8 ppg;  in 2012, Chryst’s first year and with the DC job being held by committee we gave up 21.1 ppg.  Then, in House’s first go-round, we dropped to allowing 27.2 ppg.  That is a big difference and even though we improved our record from 6-7 to 7-6, the defense didn’t help much with that.  Since our offense may not be scoring much more than last year’s 26.6 points it is critical that we lower our opponents scoring this season.

   I’m a believer that just as players understand the game and play better in their second year of college ball coaches and coordinators do also.  Am I expecting a Top Ten defense all of a sudden?  No.  We don’t have the talent on that side of the ball to do that.  Am I expecting a marked improvement, especially in House’s defensive play calling which in turn will allow what talent we do have to be effective?  Yes.  Because that one year of experience in that important coaching position helps immensely.

   Secondly, another of point of concern is Coach Breckterfield work with the defensive tackles and Coach Palermo’s work with the Defensive Ends.  We know that the defensive line’s effectiveness rests in trying to fill two big departures in Donald and Ezell but what we don’t know is how well these two coaches as the main source of guidance are going to handle that.  We have enough young raw talent along that line to at least fill out a decent 1st and 2nd string as long as they are coached well.

   My concern is if the staff is going to be able to take that talent along with the players’ youth and inexperience and develop solid and aggressive players who can fill the void.  Aggressive is a key word here as both FR and rsFR have it hard to effectively go at a 100% effort clip for 60 minutes and 13 games at the college level.  It is a big job those two coaches have and one I think the season rests on.

   Third would be how our offensive coordinator is going to be able to free up our most effective and explosive yard gainer in Quicksilver Z.  Boyd.  We know he’ll line up at WR and we are pretty sure at this point that Garner will be opposite him as the other WR (I haven’t seen 4* rookie Adonis Jennings yet).  The question is how good will Garner, and in turn the TEs, be to be able to pull some defenders off Boyd.  If they can’t not then the OC will have to find touches elsewhere for Boyd using swing routes, wheels, etc.  Last season Boyd ran the ball 11 times for 108 yards which is an astronomical 9.8 ypc.  Most of those were end arounds and sweeps to get Boyd free from having a defender in his face and to where he could get ‘in space’.  But there are a myriadof other routes he can run as a RB as shown below.

   

Now, I’m not sure our OC is going to use Boyd like this often but I love that diagram so much I had to include it.  Stare at it long enough and you might have a seizure.    I hope we don’t call many pass plays out of the backfield for Boyd to the right side of the defense as those are pretty violent;  “Stab”, “Cut”, “V(ivisect)”  “Stop” and “Flat(ten)” and “Shoot”.   Hey, I’m all for a mild rebuke if a kid screws up during a game but to allow opponents to do that crap to him is a step too far.

An option to get the ball in his hands, as crazy as it sounds, is to use him as a straight RB in a run offense every so often, including off-tackle and draw plays.  He’s got a great RB pedigree from HS and he’s the fastest and shiftiest guy we have.  He’s no small kid at 6’2″ and 190 and could physically take doing it if needed.  This would be especially good if a 3rd WR, perhaps Adonis Jennings, steps up and produces to allow Boyd to vacate the WR spot for 3-6 carries a game.  Controversial I know and I may be a bit hypocritical with it because I don’t want Boyd to have any additional chances to be hurt, but his talent is so versatile and so good that it could be very effective if used in moderation.  In addition, it would add another worry for the opposing DC to game plan stopping him.  I kind of doubt we’ll see him much in a traditional RB role but  it would be a great change of pace from Conner and/or James – two stockier and more power guys.

Trying to get up to practice both this Friday’s full contact practice and next week for the 1st scrimmage  – I’ll keep all informed.





The first few games will determine what Connor does on D. Will James, Ibraham and Bennett do well enough at RB to let Connor jump over to the D side as well as let him rest.

Comment by notrocketscience 08.08.14 @ 1:27 pm

It will work both ways. If the other RBs do well and the DEs not so, then eventually Conner will play more defense. But, if Conner proves to be by far the best RB and the DL is doing an adequate job, then Conner may only see action on defense at the end of games.

My personal thought is that the DL needs more help than the RB position … while also reminded that there are 2 DEs on the field but just 1 RB at any one time.

Comment by wbb 08.08.14 @ 1:50 pm

@Comment by PittofDreams 08.08.14 @ 12:44 pm

We’re not talkin’ about him taking 50 snaps/game on D… HCPC already floated out 8 as a number I think? That’s basically 1 snap per series.. Hardly enough to create a ‘fatigue factor’.

I mean c’mon. Most of these guys played both ways in high school anyway… and I’m talking every snap, every series.

Now… After a (much publicized) conditioning program that has these kids in the best shape of their life… it’s too much for him to go chase the QB once every 20 minutes??

Give me a break…

The more I think about it, the more I start to see HCPC perspective… that everyone is blowing this waaay out of proportion.

Guys gonna chase the QB a couple times a game… No more, no less.

Comment by BostonsCommon 08.08.14 @ 2:33 pm

ACC/Maryland settle suit for $31 million.

I thought it’d end up being around 20M.

Comment by Dan 08.08.14 @ 3:11 pm

Thomas and Gonzalez interviews today. They have really grown up since being freshmen. They are in a position to have a major impact. We need them to have great senior years. As far as rushing the passer Thomas says “I’m coming”. They both look big and strong. Only 11 seniors on the team. Glad these guys hung in there.

Comment by gc 08.08.14 @ 4:09 pm

I agree. Eight plays per game or so is nothing.

Comment by notrocketscience 08.08.14 @ 4:37 pm

Caw – looking back at the PITT Archives it shows that under DW & Phil Bennett in ’09 &’10 our defenses gave up 19 ppg – both years ending up in the Top 20 in scoring defense.

We won’t see that this season.

Writing up my practice visit as we speak.

Comment by Reed 08.08.14 @ 6:13 pm

and it continues … Pitt loses out on 2 CBs today — one to PSU (a longshot for Pitt) and the other to WVU (Pitt was a finalist)

Comment by wbb 08.08.14 @ 7:11 pm

That’s why they play the games. The stats will speak for themselves in about four months, until that time all of this speculation is just so much BS prognostication.

Comment by Dr. Tom 08.08.14 @ 7:18 pm

gc – couldn’t agree more re: Gonzalez and Thomas. Both have had their ups and downs and hung in throughout. Both are gifted athletically and appear to have matured into leaders. Their play may well be the key to the entire defense this year.

Re: PPG against, I’m not sold on House, but given the offenses Pitt faced last year, I thought the D performed relatively well. Rather than comparing PPG to prior years, look at the points Pitt gave up compared to each opponent’s average PPG in 2013.

Of the 11 D-1 teams that Pitt faced, they held 8 of them to less than their season average for points scored. Almost a touchdown per game less. Only Duke, UNC, and Miami scored more than their average PPG vs. Pitt. And 2 of UNC’s TDs were punt returns. The Duke game was just a track meet. The Miami game, IMO, was Pitt’s worst defensive performance of the season. The D was just flat in that game.

You could argue that FSU could have scored 60. You could argue that teams pad their PPG vs. cupcakes. But the fact is that overall, Pitt did better than most teams did against the same competition last year.

I’m willing to give House a pass and see what transpires this year. My primary issue, as many have stated, is defensive recruiting. It’s almost non-existent. That cannot continue. But that is on Chryst as much as House.

Comment by Iron Duke 08.08.14 @ 9:04 pm

I think PC is just trying to generate some buzz around PITT football. (hey look we got a 2 way player)

As he hinted in the interview with Dejan that playing Connor at DE, was not really in the cards.

I doubt very seriously if he would risk a 1000 yard (he would have been without missing the ODU game and parts of others) true freshmen proven RB, with moving him to an unproven spot when we are very thin at RB.

Maybe like I said previously in the 4rth quarter of a 1 score game, the opposing team has it for one last chance and they put him in, ala Pizza Bowl.

Wasn’t the guy who left for NC State, the DC in 2012 ? Dave Huxtable. It was only ‘by committee’ for the bowl game.

Comment by Emel 08.08.14 @ 9:26 pm

Hard to believe we can’t recruit highly rated defensive players.

I mean we ONLY HAD the winner of EVERY frickin major college Defensive award there is, last year.

Not to mention, Pitt has produced NFL defensive stars like the best CB in the NFL, Darrelle Revis.

With ammunition like that, it shouldn’t be hard to get highly rated players with NFL ambitions signed on the dotted line.

Comment by Emel 08.08.14 @ 9:31 pm

The year to make hay in defensive recruiting with Aaron Donald as your poster boy, was this year.

I don’t give House a pass on that.

How many times are you going to have the Outland, Lombardi, Nagurski and Bednarik Award winner on your team.

If you can’t recruit to PITT alone, you should be able to recruit to Donald’s success.

Unfricken believable

Comment by Emel 08.08.14 @ 9:35 pm

Well Pitt just made Stockers top 5,fingers crossed.

Comment by pd 08.08.14 @ 9:44 pm

Here’s who NC State hired to be their Strength & Conditioning Coach:

Head strength and conditioning coach Jason Veltkamp oversees all of the strength and conditioning efforts for Wolfpack football. The 18-year veteran came to NC State after spending five seasons in the same capacity at Arkansas. Veltkamp has worked with 47 NFL draft picks in his career.

Prior to arriving at Arkansas in 2008, Veltkamp spent four years (2004-07) as the head strength and conditioning coach for football at Louisville. During his three years with that program, the Cardinals earned trips to the Liberty, Gator and Orange bowls. From 2001-03, the Bozeman, Mont., native was the director of strength and conditioning at the University of Utah after working as an assistant from 1999-2000.

Comment by Emel 08.08.14 @ 9:45 pm

Is Pedo State on that list ?

Comment by Emel 08.08.14 @ 9:54 pm

Emel, PITT, Maryland, Cuse, Duke, Wisky.

Comment by pd 08.08.14 @ 10:33 pm

Pitt recruiting may be more difficult in the coming years. Big 5 conferences will most likely be able to give “likeness” money to their respective recruits. Example, Braxton Miller sells signed college football cards to highest bidder. Will make a couple hundred thousand a year in “fees” alone whilst in college. Also, the big programs will give a $5k per year stipend to players, plus they will also be allowed to work which means back to the $40k a year job to turn off lights at the stadiums.

Say goodbye to the MAC conference. They cannot afford this and an improved meal plan and extravagant living corridors and paying for families to travel to away games. It is going to get ugly. The big question is whether Pitt will compete against this. Selling the university and academics has been flushed down the toilet. It is no longer about academics or even the pretense of athletics. This new power given to the big 5 conferences will either make Pitt relevant or a bottom feeder. My initial sense is that it will help recruiting in that Pitt will take three and sometimes four star recruits that want to get paid and all the other benefits, away from the macs and other teams that just can’t afford to pay. This will be an interesting debate.

Can’t wait for a practice update.

Comment by dhuffdaddy 08.08.14 @ 11:08 pm

Oh that’s good pd….cause Coatesville kids seem to matriculate to Creepy Valley a lot.

He’s got 2 Big Joke teams and 3 ACC one’s.

Wisconsin is the odd one in the bunch.

Comment by Emel 08.08.14 @ 11:13 pm

yea I’m leery dhuff,

since Pitt administrators have rarely stepped up in the past to make PITT relevant in major college football. And when they did, it was in short spurts, which has greatly effected our fan base and attendance.

Comment by Emel 08.08.14 @ 11:18 pm

So now college football is (officially) just minor league system for NFL.

Comment by pd 08.08.14 @ 11:53 pm

I have a sad feeling that college FB just widened the gap between the haves and the have-nots, and then the next step will be a further widening of the gap where the top 20% will prosper even further

I have long felt that Pitt and other schools of their ilk already have little probability of a national title as it is …. and the chances will decrease even more

Comment by wbb 08.09.14 @ 6:26 am

Looks like there was a draw on the goal line yesterday.

link to blogs.post-gazette.com

Thomas, Durham and Conner made plays for the D.

Comment by gc 08.09.14 @ 6:37 am

It sure seems like college football as we have known it will soon be gone. I think a lot depends on what sort of rules the Big 5 establish and how well they are enforced. If it becomes a free-for-all with no $ limits, it could get ugly for all but the top 15-20 schools, which incidentally are almost all state-funded institutions.

Comment by Iron Duke 08.09.14 @ 7:26 am

@dhuffdaddy, exactly. Have said this for a couple years. One or two people on occasion would tell me I was exaggerating.

Ha Ha!!! A can of worms has been opened that has not been seen before in college athletics.

Who’s policing?? The Big 5 themselves?? That’s a laugh.

Everyone gets 5K (or whatever number you want to put in there), lmao, sure, sure. Alabama and Texas and Florida State aren’t gonna be winking at the kids and telling them, don’t worry, we got a little extra for you??

The problem is, even though we all know there has been some cheating and pay for play crap in college athletics for years, it still was a big deal when someone got caught cheating.

This will make it so much easier for the media, fans, public to not even care if someone is cheating.

“hey, I heard Auburn gave that RB a car”, “so what, they all do it, besides they’re all getting paid anyhow”.

On an interesting note, I do wonder how the women’s teams, and for that matter the mens teams other than football and basketball are going to look at this and the football and basketball players??

I know, the football and basketball bring the money in.

Tell that to a pack of NOW women.

Comment by Dan 08.09.14 @ 8:19 am

College FB has always been the NFL minor league. Colleges do not own a players selling rights. We better get moving on recruiting front or we will be last in the standings.

Comment by Frank MD 08.09.14 @ 9:06 am

Currently in a working group to draft institutional standards and the discussions are troubling for a college football purist. From a Pitt perspective, the Administration better get its act together quickly or they will be left in the dust.

The mid-majors will see the biggest hit. In order to compete in the revenue producing sports, they will need to cut back on other sports. The dilemma being faced is whether to give the athletes as much as they can, or face unionization. Unionization does not work and would be a runaway train. As such, the institutions want to have some control and as such, will give away the store to prevent the larger harm in their eyes. If you look back about a year, I began referencing the kids as athlete students, not the other way around. When the academic standards are released, it will finally hit home as to what is really happening at our “alleged academic institutions” and it is repulsive to the purist.

Oversight and compliance doesn’t exist right now. The NCAA has no power and they are hoping to hang on in some capacity as a defacto overseer, when in facto, they will continue to be paid by the big 5 conferences and do as they are told (i.e. sit in the corner and watch).

Comment by dhuffdaddy 08.09.14 @ 9:32 am

In a strange way, I agree, it could help Pitt recruiting, and also not hurt the team that badly.

First, Alabama, USC, FSU, Texas and the other top 15 are not really going to see their recruiting classes go up.

THEY ARE UP!! As long as you only have a certain number of players you can have on a team, scholarship, that’s it.

They may fight over some recruits against each other, but they already have all 5’s and 4’s on their rosters.

I’m not particularly happy about this, but like you said Dhuff, the 3’s and an occasional 4 that would suprise people and go to a MAC school (which does certainly happen), and also those kids that would go to Cincinati, UCONN, South Florida, a Mountain West school, Conference USA,

will most likely pass on the reason they may have went to those schools (the coaches, near their hometown, how they were recruited, liked them as a kid, Dad or Mom went their), and certainly be more focused on definitely getting into one of the Big 5 conferences to get paid.

Enormous help, eh, probably not. But the days of seeing a recruit with those “other” schools on their list will probably be over.

The days of the “2” will probably be coming to an end in the Big 5.

Comment by Dan 08.09.14 @ 11:13 am

Breckterfield is always the subject of question, at best, and derision, at worst. But no one ever remembers that he was Aaron Donald’s defensive line coach for his last two years, when he went from just another defensive tackle to the best in college football at that position. Everyone seems to assume that AD did that all on his own, but I can help but wonder whether Anoke doesn’t deserve at least a little bit of the credit for Donald’s development.

Comment by Nwe York Panther 08.11.14 @ 2:03 am

Powered by WordPress © PittBlather.com

Site Meter