masthead.jpg

January 30, 2013

All The “What Ifs” Suck

Filed under: Basketball — Chas @ 8:39 am

Late, but this is what happens when you don’t watch the game until 3 am and then have to try and function the rest of the day as if you still got a normal day of sleep. You just try to get through and try not to think too much.

There’s a lot that could be argued was a positive from the game. The team fought back hard on the road. They were so close to breaking Louisville’s spirit in the final couple minutes. Pitt got a better handle on the press. Adams and Taylor were strong offensively on rebounds and finishing.

But, no one really cares about that. The thing that makes this loss so tough is the volume of “ifs.” From the overarching theme to the individual moments. This game was loaded with the “what if” and “if only” scenarios where Pitt ends up on the winning end.

 

From the vague, “if only” Pitt had shot even 50% on free throws, to Tray Woodall missing that front-end of the one-and-one with 44 seconds left and Pitt down 3. Or if 54% FT shooter Chane Behanan doesn’t go 2-for-2 on his free throws 20 seconds later.

“If only” Talib Zanna wasn’t so completely unable to get anything to go these days. A 2-9 shooting night that follows 3-9 shooting in each of the prior games. “If only” Trey Zeigler and J.J. Moore could have finished their drives to the basket with — well — actually putting the ball in the basket.

To the questionable officiating that led to fouls limiting James Robinson in the first half — and helping Louisville open up a bigger lead — to taking a surprisingly effective Dante Taylor out of the game in the second half.

The front court, constantly overplaying in front of the basket or simply failing to rotate on defense. Leaving their man for easy slamdunks when the ball was passed to said abandoned man going to the basket.

The backcourt struggling to make a pass and holding the ball too long. Or Lamar Patterson spending too long looking for his own shot, but never taking it.

Then there are the “whys.” Why did that have to be the night Russ Smith has a good night? Or Gorgui Dieng turns into a monster?

Which is why this game sucked in the end. So many ways Pitt could have come away with a win. Not just one play, one bad call, one shot. Just a multitude of ways that they could have come away with a win.





Frustrating to watch. This team is strides better than last year, but still has a ways to go.

Comment by Pitt it IS 01.30.13 @ 9:11 am

Maybe they could bring Shaq in to show them how free throws are really done…

Comment by Pitt it IS 01.30.13 @ 9:12 am

Too many dunks for Lville and too many missed free throws for Pitt pretty much sums it up.

Comment by Coach Ditka 01.30.13 @ 9:14 am

#3 ath just now at bama, word has it foster concerned

Comment by paul shannon 01.30.13 @ 9:27 am

Pitt could have been playing an intra squad scrimmage on Monday and still would have lost, because they BEAT THEMSELVES.

Comment by Dr. Tom 01.30.13 @ 9:50 am

Well put Chas..couldn’t have said it any better..that’s exactly how I felt about that game.

And because of that I see more of the same against Syracuse..I think we’ll keep it close but I think Syracuse is too strong this year to hope for a Pitt upset.

Comment by milobloom 01.30.13 @ 9:57 am

I don’t think anyone can question Talib’s efforts, he just seems to be too mechanical (and precitable) with his shots. Sleepy seems to be a bit more athletic when shooting although he lacks some strength. Adams is still a work-in-progress.

The hesitation to shoot by Lamar seems to be a trait by quite a few Pitt players through the years where they are just not confident with their shots (Tray, Durand and JJ being the exceptions.)

Comment by wbb 01.30.13 @ 9:59 am

From what I see, Zanna is not a natural basketball talent. He has to think before he does anything on the court. If you think, rather than react in basketball you are dead.

Here’s a “what if” for you. What if Zeigler, Zanna, Adams et al. changed their free throw shooting form where they were balanced with = wt distribution to both feet and tucked their shooting elbow in? What if someone made them change their form? What if the ball went in?

All you do when you practice bad form (just like a golf swing) is reenforce the bad form.

Comment by Dan 72 01.30.13 @ 10:34 am

This team seems to fall short in so many areas,yet also seems so close to putting it all together.The play from Monday that was the best example was when we stole the ball and were breaking out on a 3 on 1.The outlet pass went right to the Card defender though and led to an easy dunk.That was a 4or 5 point swing off of our good defense combined with a bad pass.Basketball is often a “comedy of errors” and as our team grows I am hoping that we are able to play well enough to force these situations to fall our way.

Comment by spiritofsection22 01.30.13 @ 10:36 am

Something I don’t understand. With a couple minutes to go, and about 1:37 to go and again with under a minute to go.

The guards bring the ball over half court, then pass the ball around and dribble around on the outside, really no one even guarding them.

Basically just kill 20 seconds off the clock. Not only is that killing precious seconds off of the game, it’s letting the defense sit back and just play 15 seconds of real, exerted defense.

I’m not the best x’s and o’s guy in hoops, certainly doesn’t look like they are setting anything up??? Rarely do I see anyone drive the middle and kick out???

Seems like we waste a lot of time on offense, doing nothing.

Maybe I’m missing the bigger picture.

Comment by Dan 01.30.13 @ 10:46 am

Dr. Tom good comments. If you grow up playing playground ball, you don’t have to think about making a reverse lay-up. It’s an instant reaction to how someone is playing you.

Despite everything the Panthers did poorly the other night in Louisville, shooting 25% from the foul line, turning the ball over 18 times, and giving up too many back door dunks, they still ALMOST WON THE GAME! So if they can improve in a few small things, it can make a BIG difference.

Comment by Justinian 01.30.13 @ 10:50 am

Can anybody decode paul shannon’s post above?

Comment by JCE 01.30.13 @ 10:57 am

JCE, I think he means the number 3 rated recruit has signed with Alabama and Robert Foster is concerned about playing time. If so that’s good. Whe go to a national Championship team you are going to have a awful lot of competition for playing time. That very well could mean sitting on the bench 3 years. From my perspective, getting to play early is big.

Comment by Justinian 01.30.13 @ 11:16 am

Justinian — Thanks!

Comment by JCE 01.30.13 @ 11:20 am

JCE–ArDarius Stewart, the #3 rated “athlete” in the 2013 football recruiting class, just verballed to Alabama, and Robert Foster is rumored to be concerned about the impact of Stewart’s commitment on Foster’s playing prospects at Alabama.

Comment by gdf 01.30.13 @ 11:22 am

Most important game is the next one. This is
not a great Pitt team. They are getting better
Nine BE games left. Beating the cuse
at home would be huge.

What’s up w/the Defense Coordinator.
Someone must have info??

Comment by JR 01.30.13 @ 11:28 am

Dan 72 – It’s like I tell the kids I coach in softball—- practice makes permanent. Not perfect, as everyone says. Permanent.

Comment by KeyboardKev 01.30.13 @ 11:43 am

Can’t practice game pressure free-throws. More than practice they need confidence.

The playing time aspect is why I’ve kept on thinking that Foster might end up back at Pitt. Bama has a ton of really good athletes and a bunch of young WRs. He is going to really have to fight for playing time at Alabama vs. playing a lot right away at Pitt.

I read a tweet or something that Chryst talked to a former NC State coach about the DC.

Comment by Wardapalooza 01.30.13 @ 11:54 am

I can understand missing free throws at the end of teh game after facing the Louisville press for a whole game, the legs tend to go and making free throws are more difficult. But most of the misses came in the first half when they should have had fresh legs.

Comment by JP 01.30.13 @ 12:03 pm

Clairton star Boyd ‘confused’ after visiting West Virginia

http://triblive.com/sports/hssports/football/3388678-74/boyd-pitt-clairton#axzz2JP60Cp91

At this point I’d say it’s 50-50 that he ends up at Pitt

Comment by Kenny Powers 01.30.13 @ 12:39 pm

if Boyd announced Pitt at that bowl game just to get some national TV time, he is confused …. I read the other day in the PG that a Clairton assistant coach said that Boyd was still committed to Pitt …. now I’m not so sure and apparently he isn’t either

Comment by wbb 01.30.13 @ 12:57 pm

I suspect opponents may be rightly targeting some of Pitt’s notably poor FT shooters when they have scoring opportunities (ie guard him, but foul rather than yield a clean look). If Adams gets the ball deep there’s no reason to concede easy FGs when you can undermine his confidence by sending him to the line. Ziegler’s increased minutes will see increased fouls — he’s already proven he can score at this level, but he hasn’t established that he can be a passable FT shooter.

Once Louisville had a lead they stayed aggressive and Pitt struggled to get back in the game by conceding opportunities at the stripe. 9 FT misses vs 3 final point difference. The math is pretty simple. Even if Pitt went %50 it’s a different game.

Comment by Ghost of Hornman 01.30.13 @ 12:58 pm

Yeah I just read an article on ESPNinsider about how Boyd’s mom is really anti-WVU. Which is good for us, but at the end of the day who knows what that amounts to. Didn’t Fosters parents really want him to go to Pitt? In the end, the kid will go where HE wants to.

Comment by Kenny Powers 01.30.13 @ 1:01 pm

@ Kenny Powers, The headline on that article said it all, “Clairton star Boyd ‘confused’ after visiting West Virginia”.

Once back home, someone offerd some insight to his confusion when they overheard him state that, “before visiting WVU I thought the only use for sheep was for their wool???

Comment by Dr. Tom 01.30.13 @ 1:30 pm

Well put Dr. Tom, well put.

Comment by Kenny Powers 01.30.13 @ 1:35 pm

Also, a 4 star WR enrolled early at Alabama so who knows what will happen. Although Boyd likes spread offense slot receivers play in all types of offenses.

Comment by Frank MD 01.30.13 @ 1:46 pm

I wish Knish and Nosmoking would give their opinions on Foster and Boyd!!!

Comment by Dan 01.30.13 @ 2:07 pm

The decision should be easy for Boyd. If he wants to go to a party school, run a lot of uncomplicated routes, catch a ton of passes and be developmentally behind when he gets drafted he should pick wvu.

If he wants to play in a pro style offense, learn the nuances of playing receiver from a former bilitnikof winner, and be a lot more pro-ready when payday comes. Oh and still catch a fair amount of balls, and have a degree that people actually respect, he should go to Pitt.

So basically Mr Boyd… do you want to party or do you want to prepare yourself for the future, football or otherwise?

Ps forgot to add the part about playing games in Ames, Iowa and oklahoma vs Miami, Boston, Chapel Hill and Atlanta

Comment by Atlanta Panther 01.30.13 @ 2:10 pm

Check out this related article on Boyd’s late recruiting push by other schools.

http://triblive.com/sports/hssports/highschoolrecruiting/3359384-74/payne-boyd-recruiting#axzz2JU5mdjW5

Now here’s the thing I’m not understanding regarding both Boyd and Foster. I understand that the “quality” of their educational experiences are of the utmost importance to each one of them. Excuse me??? Did I miss the memo that either West Virginia or Alabama, out of nowhere, have suddenly established their institutions as highly valued venues due to their academic reputations?

Hopefully Boyd’s Mom and his Clairton “bros” that are also verbal commitments to Pitt will “unconfuse” him by LOI signing day. I think that Boyd will be regretting his decision down the road IF he decides to decommit Pitt. Why? Because he would be in a position to make a truly meaningful impact with his contributions to the Pitt football program and probably early on in his career.

For that matter Foster’s situation would have been the same, even more so IMO. Foster especially, could have had the opportunity to be a star in his own backyard at the college level at Pitt. It will be interesting to see how his career develops at Alabama.

Now there is rumor of him doubting if he’ll get early playing time? Are you frekin kidding me? What were the Bama recruiters shoveling out to Foster in the first place? One more stellar recruit for Bama is not going to make much of a difference in that program’s situation as it pertains to Foster seeing the field early.

NEWS ALERT FOR MR. ROBERT FOSTER,,,,, please take a number and we’ll call you when it is time for you to buckle up your helmet and actually play. Don’t hold your breath there my boy. There is a ton of talent ahead of you. Expect a redshirt and hopefully you’ll get some playing time in 2014.

Hey, no worries, they still give you a National Championship ring even when you’re only riding the pine.

Comment by Dr. Tom 01.30.13 @ 2:13 pm

When I look at Boyd’s twitter feed, not that I’m putting huge stock into it, he still has a Pitt picture, retweeted something from Dorian Johnson and retweeted “I’ve seen 2976619256 tweets about *Boyd* nnot going pitt, people act like they know everything #annoying” All of this looks like Boyd is still a Pitt guy and would sign with Pitt today if he had to decide. Although, I won’t be comfortable until he actually signs.

@Dr. Tom, completely right. I’m sure the Bama recruiters were telling Foster how he’s so good he will be starting next year for the national champions. But now it’s coming down to decision time and he looks and he sees Bama is loaded everywhere. Maybe he is finally realizing that he won’t play right away. Foster will be lucky to get PT in 2014, let alone playing at all in 2013.

Comment by Wardapalooza 01.30.13 @ 2:22 pm

@ Wardspalooza, Really though, you kinda have to feel for these talented recruits during the process. It can be like getting thrown to the sharks in a sense, trying to figure out the reality of their situations and deciding what is actually best for them personally while wading through mountains of BS shoveled out by these recruiters.

Just like the pretty freshman sweetie at her first fraternaty party, gotta keep your senses about you and don’t believe all the smooth talk you hear from the handsome upperclassmen. Last thing you want is to wake up in the morning trying to find your panties in a strange bedroom, attempting to piece together what the hell happened.

Comment by Dr. Tom 01.30.13 @ 3:02 pm

Mike archer interviewed for Pitt Dc. Has ton of ties to the south. Was head coach of LSU at age of 34.

Comment by why me 01.30.13 @ 3:07 pm

Dr. Tom.

Nice metaphor.

Comment by xfmrman 01.30.13 @ 3:10 pm

Dr. Tom great comments! Reason for all the “confusion” is that it is “rug cutting” time.
Signing day is around the corner and all the BS shoveled by Bama and the Snakes is being realized as just that….BS!

Comment by Dan 72 01.30.13 @ 3:14 pm

These guys are 17 or 18 years old. They don’t all have the savy to separate bullshit from reality. One thing know I know, if possible it’s better to go somewhere where you’ll play sooner. Some very highly rated prospects get stuck behind someone else. No one wants to be a Wally Pip. For the younger guys, once Lou Gehrig went in for him, Pip never got back on the playing field.

Comment by Justinian 01.30.13 @ 3:26 pm

Dr. Tom, I like your anology. It very clearly conveys who is going to end up getting screwed.

Any player with pro aspirations who doesn’t want be in a pro-style offence is doing himself a diservice.

Comment by Justinian 01.30.13 @ 3:32 pm

What if Andrew Janocko had held onto the snap?

“What ifs” truly do suck; sometimes a beatdown is preferred.

Comment by Chuck Morris 01.30.13 @ 3:45 pm

We Joisey alumni call the sum total of “what ifs” Pittdom.

Comment by steve1 01.30.13 @ 3:59 pm

It’s not only the style of offense. Face it .. it is documented that both Boyd and Dorian Johnson would be at PSU if no sanctions. Foster is at Bama and Kugler didn’t even consider Pitt even though his old man (at the time) worked at the samepractice facility. And the main reaso that Shell staye was due to his family situation.

A few years back when T Pryor immediately ruled out Pitt because he would not be playing in front of packed stadiums said plenty. These 4 and 5 stars are being recruited by the most attarctive programs out there, and it has to be hard for them not to be swayed by the bright lights.

Comment by wbb 01.30.13 @ 4:05 pm

BTW, the Trib is now reporting that Boyd is visiting Tennessee this Friday.

Comment by wbb 01.30.13 @ 4:06 pm

@ why me, where is your source on the Mike Archer for DC interview? I can’t find info anywhere on who, if anybody, that Chryst has considered for the positon. Now, Archer sounds like a valid candidate however, of course, you realize that the position Huxtable just took at NC St. was vacated by Mike Archer when the Head Coach there got the axe. Pretty comical really, musical coaching chairs. Ranks right up there with conference realignment, often DISFUNCTIONAL!

Comment by Dr. Tom 01.30.13 @ 4:11 pm

If you are really good it doesn’t matter where you go, eg. Ben at Miami of Ohio or Randy Moss at Marshall. But you have to get on the field, Flacco had to leave Pitt to get playing time.

But I agree, if you want to play in front of 100,000 lunatic fans you go to the Big Ten or the ACC and we can’t compete with that.

If the WPIAL kids are going out of town we’ll just have to go get some out of town kids ala Hugh Green, Ricky Jackson, Mark May, LaSean McCoy, Ray Graham.

Comment by gc 01.30.13 @ 4:25 pm

Mike Vukovan of KDKA sports tweeted the Mike Archer interview

Comment by wbb 01.30.13 @ 4:26 pm

getting back to the topic of this blog … I actually had a sense of encouragement in that Pitt played like crap but was still in the game until the final minute. If Pitt beats Cuse on Saturday, then I will be feeling a lot better that this team is getting better .. slowly but improving

Comment by wbb 01.30.13 @ 4:38 pm

Yeah, that was the problem in a nutshell wbb. They did everything within their capacity to play just poor enough on multiple fronts to lose.

That game was their’s for the taking. They need to always play like they did against DePaul, although an inferior opponent, this team needs to learn how take advantage of their opportunities when they get them as well as playing without mercy when they smell their opponent’s blood on the court.

So far this is a team that is still trying to find it’s identity and leadership.

Comment by Dr. Tom 01.30.13 @ 5:00 pm

The majority of the Bball team is improving. It cant come fast enuff for all of us. The core of this team is built for 2013-14. Not giving up on this season, just being real and looking forward to the BEast Tourney! In addition Zanna is an ACC wimpy type 4 so he should finally improve next season. What I wouldnt give to have Blair, Troutman or even Lett for God’s sake come in for some Zanna pointers and pick him up and stuff him thru the basket. Now that’s how a man goes to the rim Talib! Get mean! Loved seeing Adams show frustration by smacking the chair the other night during time out. UPone

Comment by UPone 01.30.13 @ 5:00 pm

if mike archer is are new DC i would love it a ton of experence was with the steelers for 7 year as there LB coach but that is to good to be true.
we will end up with jackson who has all most no experence.

Comment by FRANKCAN 01.30.13 @ 5:15 pm

OK…so let me catch up…

1) Boyd is out and now Foster is in.

2) Pitt BB looks dumb now with the missed FT’s and all those ridiculous ball screens and hedges on D.

3) If Pitt loses Saturday we are still without a real quality win.

4) Pitt’s DC could wind up being a nobody after all….

5) The Pens stink on ice……(OK, I mentioned that)

Comment by Jackagain 01.30.13 @ 5:18 pm

wbb, If the Panthers begin to play good competive football, they will fill the stadium again. The schedule will be a lot better and I think the team will be better. No one wants to see the Panthers playing games against Ohio U. or Youngstown State. I you can play a good schedule and you lose a few to Clemson, Florida State, or another good team that’s ok.

Comment by Justinian 01.30.13 @ 5:21 pm

wbb I agree the progress is slow however that too gives me hope that a late breakout could propel this years team to do something special.We have had too many not reach lofty expectations it would be fantastic to surprise everyone for a change.As bad as things looked Monday on a given day we could beat just about anybody.Particularly if they underestimate us.The Georgetown game is our best of the year,but we can do better.

Comment by spiritofsection22 01.30.13 @ 5:51 pm

I agree. Note that in the past (except for last year) we always peaked in January because we usually had 3 experienced starters coming back in addition to a couple others who had much prior PT. This year with 2 natural freshmen starters, a redshirt frosh and a new transfe rgetting a lot of court time, it could be we will peak in late Feb

Comment by wbb 01.30.13 @ 6:15 pm

Degrees? Great Educational Experience? If you guys think this is even in the Top 3 for these kids you guys are crazy. It’s about Winning! Exposure! Draft Status. It isn’t about education… Unless you are going to Stanford the schools are all about the same. As far as Pitt getting Foster, there is zero chance. He is going to Bama and I wish him the best. Boyd looks like he fell in love with the WR’s success of Steadman Bailey and Tavon Austin. In that system he could also carry the ball a lot and he probably see’s an opportunity to play as a freshman. Where will he go? Who knows but I know the previous years garbage schedule and the debacle that is Pitt’s AD Dept isn’t helping. There is little excitement created by that band of misfits led by Peterson. In the end I think he will stay at Pitt hopefully….

Comment by Upittbaseball 01.30.13 @ 6:16 pm

i can’t fault any wpial 4 or 5 star kid who rejects pitt to go play in front of 100k people in the SEC, Big 10 or Big 12. pitt can’t compete w/ that…yet. win big in the acc and heinz will be full.

Comment by scott 01.30.13 @ 6:22 pm

if Boyd does go to Tennessee this friday, then I guess that means he is not head over heels on WVU … just looking at the bright side

Comment by wbb 01.30.13 @ 6:35 pm

As I said before the Louisville game if Pitt makes 70% of their FT’s against Syracuse they will beat the Orange. But up to now 70% seems like a dream for this Pitt team.

Comment by MariettaMike 01.30.13 @ 7:01 pm

One WR isn’t going to make a difference, so who cares what Tyler Boyd wants to do. Pryor didn’t exactly have a hall of fame career. Wide receivers are a dime a dozen.

Pitt bball just can’t seem to win a close game against a quality team. Some of it is youth, some is coaching, but the biggest reason is lack of execution from the veteran players (Woodall & Patterson).

Pitt has a very solid team. Hopefully we can get a win on Saturday.

Comment by omar 01.30.13 @ 7:34 pm

Pryor actually was MVP in the 2 BCS games he played (Rose vs Oregon and Sugar vs Arkansas) while leading OSU to its 1st BCS win in 4 or 5 years. He also is in Top 5 all time in many offensive categories.

Of course, all he will be remembered for will be those tattoos even though he was just one of several Buckeye players who took part.

Comment by wbb 01.30.13 @ 7:42 pm

On recruiting, the final decision should never be left to an 18 year old. Sorry! The parents need to step in and bring reality back to their child. Emphasis on child. The parents typically have heard enough bs in their respective lives to direct their son or daughter to the right place. It is disrespectful in my opinion, for a son or daughter to go against their parents wishes. Listen, how many of us on here actually wish we would have listened to our parents when we were 17 or 18? Only later in life do we realize we actually made the wrong choice and matters would have turned out beeter had we actually listened when we thought we knew better.

Anyone remember Andrew Johnson? Parents wanted him to go to Pitt. He chose Miami because of the party atmosphere and because they were always highly ranked at that time. The coaches fed him the bs about how important he was to their future success and how he would see the field early. Fast forward a couple of years and he was competing against 4 and 5 stars to see the field. He couldn’t beat them out, didn’t have enough game tape for pro scouts and didn’t finish his career there. Disappearing into obscurity. To hear jim tell it today, he made the right choice and got caught in the numbers game and then had an injury during his junior year and never finished.

Really? Believe what you want. The parent should have made the final call. That is why they are the parent. Not a posse of other commits partying with you and trying to make you feel at home or a coach promising the world to each of them. Complete exploitation of kids emotions.

Robert Foster from the north will never fit in with the south. Unless you have lived in the south after being a life long northener, you just don’t get it until you live it. They don’t like us! Never have, never will, despite their bs. Use you for what you can give them…absolutely. Tyler Boyd, was recruited this past weekend by a posse of player’s and coaches that are desperate. Holgorsen didn’t recruit Geno, Steadman or Austin. They are perilously close to losing relevance because they are in a conference with their closest league competitor 900 miles away. They must promise the world to get kids. Step back from the emotions and parents, step into and help shape their careers because they are your children and that is what you signed on for when you had them. Put simply, parents don’t get paid to direct their children. Coaches get paid handsomely to promise the world and get kids in for the most part.

That is why Paul Chryst will be successful. The parents of kids get him and trust him. And, he doesn’t bs them. Holgorsen, Fraud Graham and Saban are professional bs’ers.

Comment by dhuffdaddy 01.30.13 @ 8:08 pm

I’ve said this a few times and no one has suggested anything…WHAT IS OUR IDENTITY AND WHO IS THE LEADER OF THIS TEAM??

Comment by Keith 01.30.13 @ 8:16 pm

dhuffdaddy, In a perfect world, it should be a family decision. The athlete’s parents have more life experience and know him a heck of a lot better than anyone else. What’s more, they actually care about him. Good post.

Comment by Justinian 01.30.13 @ 8:27 pm

Duff daddy…. Lived in NC 2 years…. LA 8 years and now Texas 1 year. Never felt like an outsider…The south is basically covered with Northerners who moved for work and better opportunities. Saban is from WV. Texas is practically PA. My neighborhood is largely PA, OH and Mid west. I don’t buy that nonsense. Foster will do great and I look forward to him representing PA when Bama plays Texas AM or LSU. As far as trusting your parents….neither wanted me to go to Pitt. I had 6 offers and Pitt was 4th on their list. Chryst is not a good recruiter. He better get someone who can do it for him. If you can’t get local kids that live 20 mins away that says something.

Comment by Upittbaseball 01.30.13 @ 8:27 pm

I also believe a 18 year old isn’t a child. If raised right one should be able to make up their own minds. They can see through bs just as good as a 55 year old parent.

Comment by Upittbaseball 01.30.13 @ 8:31 pm

UPitt, I disagree I think in a family, the discussion is an important part of the process. Just to go along, if you think it isn’t the right fit, doesn’t benefit anyone. You let them know what you feel and what you think. If when has everything been discussed and they still feel that way, then it’s ultimately their decision.

Comment by Justinian 01.30.13 @ 8:57 pm

@Huffdady: Well said.

@Upittbaseball: Parts of Texas and NC and definitely Atlanta may be northernized but I can guarantee you that Alabama, Mississippi and the state of Georgia 30 miles outside of Atlanta are most definitely not.

Bottom Line: Chryst’s honesty and candor, his “style” if you will is going to attract the right kind of recruits over time. If we miss out on a couple or few high star recruits who couldn’t see through the BS its not the end of the world and maybe they weren’t right for the program anyway. But if they in the end are able to see through it all and make the right choice, then it’s a good thing for everybody.

Comment by Atlanta Panther 01.30.13 @ 8:58 pm

a while back i said tenn was in trouble, there is more, the kid from carlise should be a nice surprise at wr,is chryst agood recruiter how would u know yet,will foster do great,only excellent is acceptable in ala, they have at least 3 of him,will be at syr game with nosmo and nick perry,keep an eye on this junior day ,notice how many jucos just south of us watch their nonqualifiers,our commits will change by at least three before signing day ,ours are not the only ones rethinking, thats a long one 4 me

Comment by paul shannon 01.30.13 @ 9:12 pm

We are going to have to disagree UPitt. LA is really not south. It is kind of west on my map. California, we could all probably agree, is their own animal.

Go to Georgia, Alabama, South Carolina, Mississippi and Florida. They still fly the confederate flag. Texas wants to secede and North Carolina is…well, not completely southern, but I’ll give you that.

You reference more northeners in your current dealings. We are not looking at your neighbors upitt. To be fair, look at his projected teammates and come back to me with your argument.Look at the recruiting class at Alabama and see how many come from the north! It is a simple exercise, just do it. Do it with LSU and the other southern redneck states.

Perhaps all of your stars aligned right at 18 and you made all the right choices without parental guidance. Maybe your parents had Pitt 4th on their list because they saw something better for you going elsewhere. Perhaps playing time, education, etc. I don’t know your particular circumstance. I am sure you would not have changed a thing in your decision-making process as an 18 year old.

You made my point on both of your arguments. Typically I enjoy your negative posts about recruiting and Paul Chryst because they are laughable. Pitt finished in the rankings of regular season play, around 65th. Yet, their current recruiting class is somewhere between 19th and 30th. That to me is remarkable!

I do agree that Steve Pederson is not the right person as an AD. Again, I look at facts. Pull the AD profiles of the top 20 football program AD’s and compare resume’s. Are guy is not even on the map.

Comment by dhuffdaddy 01.30.13 @ 9:13 pm

As a life long salesman and teacher of sales, I can tell you that the “truth” works every time.
Quietly spoken if possible. Chryst has told these recruits. If they still want to go elsewhere, God Bless em.

I am close to being astonished at the success Chryst has had at recruiting with little to build on preceeding him. We will all know “the truth” come Feb 6th.

Comment by Dan 72 01.30.13 @ 9:23 pm

“Our” not, are. Pressing Enter before proofing = malpractice in my business!

Comment by dhuffdaddy 01.30.13 @ 9:42 pm

Dan, I’ve been dealing with industrial clients all my life and I’ve always been honest with them. I believe most people appreciate candor and honesty. It doesn’t always get you the work everytime, but it’s the best way to go over the long haul. Most people don’t like the hard sell, and they develop bullshit filters.

Comment by Justinian 01.30.13 @ 9:43 pm

I think who comes to pitt and who does not.
is not as important as who the DC will be
if it is some one who is lurning on the job
who has never been a DC before god help us.

if it is some one who knows what he is doeing i think we could be a real good team next year.

and if not then we are rolling the dice and
i just hope it doesent come up craps

Comment by FRANKCAN 01.30.13 @ 9:46 pm

@Frankcan

Well next year is a crap shoot anyway.

We have no clue if the QB will work out.
We have no gamebreaker/big play guy as Ray Ray is
gone gone. As he made the offense go (see the dreadful offense of the Bowl Game)

And we’re going into next season with more than likely at least 3 new offensive linemen.

Lots of question marks. Both in player personnel and coaching personnel.

Comment by EMel 01.30.13 @ 9:51 pm

As far as hoops and all the “ifs”.

We need some signature wins, as we sit presently at #49 in RPI, which when you factor in the over 20 guaranteed bids of the mid major conf’s., put us squarely ……..
…….. on the Bubble.

Need to get a Signature Win this Saturday !!!

Comment by EMel 01.30.13 @ 9:57 pm

EMel dont worry abought the QB if he could do what he did with tino savage will look like a all pro chryst will make him look good i trust that will happen.
the o line will be as good or better becuse savage wont hold the ball all day.

but i just like the odds better if we have a DC who knows what he is doeing insted of one lurning on the job.

Comment by FRANKCAN 01.30.13 @ 10:04 pm

Go to Georgia, Alabama, South Carolina, Mississippi and Florida. They still fly the confederate flag.
Comment by dhuffdaddy 01.30.13 @ 9:13 pm

lol only South Carolina still flys the Confederate Flag at their State House.
On the other hand they voted in a female Indian-American Governor. First in the nation in that regard.

Comment by EMel 01.30.13 @ 10:06 pm

Duff daddy… No worries on disagreeing. It’s okay bud. When I referred to LA…. I meant as in Louisiana not LA, CA. I lived in SEC Country big time…. We’re there a ton of Northemers there around me? No, but the southerners I encountered were very nice, warm and receptive to my Pitt flag and steelers flag. Maybe because I also flew the LSU flag, wife is alum. There were the occasional Yankee this and the Big East jokes….but all in all great family people who had your back. Like the burgh with a southern draw.

Comment by Upittbaseball 01.30.13 @ 10:06 pm

Did I make the right choice picking Pitt? I think so but I’m sure I would have done just as well elsewhere but I did enjoy my time in Oakland. I made the final say but did ask for advice from Mom and Dad and a few coaches. At the end of the day I made the choice with their support.

Comment by Upittbaseball 01.30.13 @ 10:09 pm

Savage hasn’t played a down on the field since 2010.

While I hope he works out, it’s a crap shoot. And we have no one with any college experience other than Trey, who got to throw a whopping 2 passes the entire year.

So Savage better work out for PC’s sake.

Agree we don’t need another…on the job trainee,
for DC. :-)

Comment by EMel 01.30.13 @ 10:09 pm

Duff, last thing…. Fly down and let’s go to a game at Death Valley or Bama… It’s a awesome experience. I will buy the tickets if you get down this way. I hope one day before I die when can have an atmosphere even half of those programs. We are on the right path. But playing DII schools….more Pederson nonsense sets us back years.

Comment by Upittbaseball 01.30.13 @ 10:12 pm

Good comments Dr. Tom and dhuffdaddy…

Chryst not a good recruiter? Everything I read that everyone here is finding shows consistently ALL the kids saying the like and get along with the coaching staff, they are getting the respect of the HS coaches, parents,… and now we read how they are getting really well positioned with the kids for 2014!

Dan and Justinian are right on about sales and honesty in terms of top sales.

Chryst needs a good recruiter??? What like “slick Willy” who can lie with the best of the scum? Don’t think so.

I bet you PC is honest when he says he tells these kids to go check out other places, etc. He does not want buyer’s remorse or weak minded people who will go for all the BS and hype anyway. (and I am not knocking 18yr olds… it must be tough dealing with all this stuff).

He is being smart because he is getting players that are committed to his vision for his program.

I would be shocked if Boyd switches because he has good people around him including his community and school mates. He is just working through things and better he does it now than wondering ‘what if’ after he signs.

Holgorsen and WVU… I was worried about them a year ago and now you just have to wonder… good comments above… you sense emotional instability, all the coaching changes… and really… look at that travel schedule… 900 miles closest school… in the middle of no where… (seems like the basketball team is enjoying it!!!). brutal… what kid from the northeast wants to live that life?

Foster made an informed decision and you can’t knock the kid… although folks are right about the whole playing time thing… 2015 it seems really… but when the best wants you that is hard to say no to. WVU or Tennessee ain’t ‘bama now…

Comment by PittScript 01.30.13 @ 10:14 pm

EMel savage will be better then tino think abought it.
did you not think tino should have been on the bench.
did you not say in so many words tino sucked.
at least savage can see over the line and throw the deep ball no more 8 in the box.
chryst all ways make his QB better then they are savage will be fine.

Comment by FRANKCAN 01.30.13 @ 10:29 pm

good insights on Chryst from his brother… end of article in particular.

http://triblive.com/sports/nfl/3379117-74/chryst-geep-paul#axzz2JWMIrEc3

Comment by PittScript 01.30.13 @ 10:40 pm

@omar — you’re spot on. That’s been a problem all year. Look at Woodall’s overall play in the L’ville game — as damaging, if not more, than his missed FT at the end of the game.

Comment by velvil 01.30.13 @ 11:13 pm

i can’t fault any wpial 4 or 5 star kid who rejects pitt to go play in front of 100k people in the SEC, Big 10 or Big 12. pitt can’t compete w/ that…yet. win big in the acc and heinz will be full.

Comment by scott 01.30.13 @ 6:22 pm

lol There are very few places with 100K stadiums.
Seems to be a misconception that the media feeds about some of these conf’s.

Big 10 has 2, Michigan & Pedo State
Big 12 has one, Texas
SEC has 2, Alabama & Tennessee.

Pitt plays in a bigger stadium than Ole Miss, Miss State, Vanderbilt(40K) and Kentucky in the SEC. The ones with bigger stadiums are mostly far larger student bodies than Pitt(especially those living on campus) and (key*) are in College Towns

Pitt plays in a bigger stadium than K-State(50K), Kansas(50K), TCU(50K), Texas Tech(61K), Iowa State (55K), Baylor (50k), Wvcc (60K) and Ok. State (60K). So therefore we play in a far nicer stadium with a larger capacity than 80% of the Big 12.

And as far as the Big Joke er I mean 10, Pitt has a bigger stadium than Illinois (60K), Indiana (53k), Maryland (54K), Minnesota (51K), Northwestern (47K), Purdue (62K), Rutgers (52K) and only a few thousand seats less than Iowa (70K)
So therefore over half of that joke conf. Again these are very large student body colleges with 5-10 times more kids living on campus than Pitt.

So as you can see playing in front of 100K might happen once or twice for a school in these conf’s.

Big Deal !

Comment by EMel 01.30.13 @ 11:14 pm

Funny how the media has people thinking the BIg 12 is all Texas & Oklahoma type programs and teams.

Where in reality they’re all dwarfs, small rinky dink stadiums(mostly in the middle of nowhere), not much football tradition, history and success on the field. Dwarfs. If you can’t fill up a little stadium in the middle of nowhere, that is truly pathetic.

Same thing with the Little 10 er Big 10.
It use to be just Ohio Fake & Michigan, the others never had a chance of getting to the Rose Bowl. Still mostly programs with little or no football history of tradition. Not compared to PITT.

F*ck em ALL !!

Comment by EMel 01.30.13 @ 11:21 pm

Tennessee just got a verbal from the #2 wide receiver in the country.

Comment by Mailman 01.31.13 @ 12:35 am

@ upittbaseball, there you go, now that is why you should listen to your God damn parents! Look at the way you turned out!

Comment by dr. Tom 01.31.13 @ 7:34 am

BTW, I’m just messin with you Upittbaseball.

@ Emel, didn’t you get the memo on our new QB, he will be head a shoulders over our recently departed 5th yr Senior, his name,,,,,,
Anybody B. Tino. ABT for short!

I cannot tell you how pleasant it will be to see whoever under center this year, other than you know who.

Comment by dr. Tom 01.31.13 @ 7:45 am

Heinz Field isn’t the problem, it’s the empty seats at Heinz Field that are the problems. Some of that falls on the AD and our Athletic Director, but a quick solution to the problem is a simple equation.

ACC(Improved Schedule) X Winning=A Full Stadium

Conclusion, just win baby, WIN.

Comment by Dr. Tom 01.31.13 @ 7:59 am

Justinian and Dad, I have been an organizational buyer for most of my life (not currently), and the difference between organizational sales and consumer sales, as you know, is that the organization usually makes a much more informed decision than the consumer whose decision is more based on emotion. Of course, the fact that the solicitation is pre-planned via a structured RFP created by a group is extremely helpful.

To your point, honesty proves out in the long run … any false claims will certainly dampen the reputation of the seller not only to the buyer but often in the industry itself.

Then of course, there is Todd Graham who preys on desparate ADs who put themselves in a hole by not planning a valid job search. The very first time I heard Fraud in his hiring presser at Pitt, I was put off by his fast talking and ability to skirt a few of the questions put to him by focusing everything on himself … he does it a lot better than Ray Lewis, by the way.

Comment by wbb 01.31.13 @ 8:00 am

I meant Justinian and DaN (not Dad) … and no, there are no Freudian implications here

Comment by wbb 01.31.13 @ 8:01 am

Omar, I believe that the recent Pitt surge (prior to Monday’s game) was spurred on by Lamar’s improved play since the Nova game, and it is no coincidence that Pitt looked ragged offensively when he doesn’t play well (like Monday night.)

He reminds me quite of bit of your man, Wannamaker, in that when a play is not working, you can rely on him to create something. Yes, Lamar is way behind Wannamaker but he is only a junior, and you may remember that Wannamker has his share of turnovers until his senior season. But overall I agree, Lamar has been disappointing for the most part this year.

Comment by wbb 01.31.13 @ 8:11 am

Emel, I love you man

Comment by rayhpgh 01.31.13 @ 8:35 am

@wbb – no worries – my dad was a shoe salesman for most of his life and I learned a great deal about honesty and building relationships from travelling with him and watching him work.

Comment by Pitt Dad 01.31.13 @ 8:37 am

Mike Archer for DC? I thought that would be a possiblilty. He had a horrible year. I watched two games they blew in the last minutes giving up long touchdowns.
Can’t always blame the coordinator and one year does not make or break a coach. He has the experience.

Comment by notrocketscience 01.31.13 @ 8:48 am

Recruiting is such a diffent animal from real world sale. A recruiter isn’t selling a product he’s selling the idea that the school is going to get you to the NFL. And the recruiter only has to sell it to you once, because once you sign your letter of intent you are stuck unless you go through the lenghty transfer process. So say a Bama recruiter sold Foster on getting playing time right away, but then Saban tells Foster he is redshirting the day before the first game. Was Foster lied to? Yes. Does it matter? No. He’s stuck there. Is a potential recruit going to be affected by that lie? Probably not because that lying recruiter is going to sell the next potential recruit the same B.S. and he’s going to point to a guy like Juilio Jones as what Bama can do for him.

Onto basketball, I’ve been thinking that Woodall has seemed a bit slow and shakey with the ball this year. Not sure why, maybe it’s just cause James Robinson is good with the ball that he makes Woodall look worse.

When it comes to Lamar, I don’t get his reluctance to shoot wide open jumpers. He’s a good shooter and his reluctance usually just leads to something bad happening like a 3 seconds call or a rushed last second shot. Agressive Lamar is good, passive Lamar is bad. Wanamaker was much more well rounded. Wannamaker had more turnovers but he also had to handle the ball more and had more assits. Also Wannamaker somehow averaged almost 2 rebounds more a game as a junior than Lamar currently is, which shouldn’t be the case. Although, maybe it’s just cause Wannamaker was the man.

Comment by Wardapalooza 01.31.13 @ 9:03 am

@ Wardapalooza, point well taken, recruiting college athletes is more like,,,,,,recruiting.
By that I mean that it is like assembling the right employee mix for your company so that you can be successful longtem into the future with your staff. So the employer/recruiter still is going to benefit in the longrun by being forthright and honest regarding the job description, employee benefit package, work environment and future for promotion potential, etc.

If you hoodwink the applicant at the front end of that relationship you will find yourself saddled with a disgruntaled employee done the road. Not a good situation if you want to get the best performance out of your team. So at least the thin veil of honesty should be the foundation of any recruiter’s process or else the organization is going to become disfunctional down the line.

I totally disagree with your concept that football recruiters are selling an “idea” and not a product. IMO, Alabama is currently selling a PRODUCT, and a very successful product at that. But I will give you the fact that guys like Paul Chryst ARE selling an “idea” or a “vision” as I like to define it. Kind of like the real estate agent that has the knack to embelish the potential home buyer’s own imagination by describing how beautiful their house is going to look when built on the empty house lot when they first visit it.

Does ANYBODY know what Pitt’s football program is going to look like in 3 to four years, I sure don’t, but I still like what Coach Chryst is selling right now because he has the vision and his soft sell kind of fits what he is offering to recruits. Considering the last couple of years that Pitt has been through, based on the CURRENT PRODUCT that Pitt actually has to sell, I’m surprised that we have the quality of recruits in this class that we do!

LOI signing day will be interesting. If we do hold onto Boyd and maybe pick up a surprise recruit on Wednesday along with the class that he has already assembled, my final assessment of Paul Chryst’s first full recruiting class of his own making will be,,,, pretty NEAT!

Comment by Dr. Tom 01.31.13 @ 10:04 am

Dr. Tom… LOL…They usually were right on… Good Luck.

Comment by Upittbaseball 01.31.13 @ 10:16 am

@Dr. Tom, just win baby, is it that simple???

Yes, yes it is!! You are correct!!!

Good example. Ole Miss hoops. Allthough they did just lose to Kentucky, they are something like 17-3, ranked in the top 15.

They didn’t even know what a basketball was there a few years ago. Now, they had to get an extra 500 SRO’s for the last couple games. Their shoebox is a wild, loud and rabid place to place hoops.

What changed the past few years?? Buildings’s the same, colors the same, nickname is the same.

Only thing that changed???

Instead of being 7-21 and at the bottom of the SEC, they are now a top ranked team, fighting with Florida for the top spot. (which by the way they play at Gainesville Sat.)

Will winning guarantee 65K overflowing at Heinz. No, of course not. We all know how it goes. Sell outs for PSU, ND and WVU.

But, winning, and a big game against Va. Tech, FSU, Clemson or N.Carolina, will now become sell outs and must see games.

Winning, will also get you a good steady crowd of 45-55K for all of the other games.

Not what they count, but actual warm bodies in the seats.

Just win baby?? Ya, actually, just win baby!!!

Comment by Dan 01.31.13 @ 10:32 am

Fantasy Camp:

Could you imagine….2nd week in November….

A 15th ranked, 9-0 or 8-1 Pitt team, having a 4th ranked, 9-0 Clemson team coming in to Heinz Field on cold, cloudy, snow flurry day, with ESPN Gameday in attendance????

The place would be over flowing and going absolutely bonkers like the Cincy game a few years ago.

Ya, not so easy, we have to be 8-1 or 9-0 and ranked in the top 20. I get that, we all get that.

Win and become a top 20 program again, and we will have many games like that and less and less of the gold seats out numbering the actual fans at the games.

Just Win Baby!!! I’m pumped up allready!!!

Comment by Dan 01.31.13 @ 10:41 am

Ole Miss will be exposed on Saturday, just like they were at home vs UK

Comment by wbb 01.31.13 @ 10:58 am

Dan – you are 100% right. And let’s definitely forget about setting that LOW goal of a 45K seat stadium on campus. Let’s think big, not small, with our move to a great conference – the ACC.

Comment by rayhpgh 01.31.13 @ 10:58 am

Marino fathered a child out of wedlock and paid hush money. She is 7 now. Wow, Super bowl week brings talk of Gays, Deer Antlers and Babies out of Wedlock.

Comment by Upittbaseball 01.31.13 @ 11:08 am

While some players are articulate, the majority are bred to be gladiators … and most of them should be seen on the field of play but not heard from.

It is embarrassing just how ignorant a ‘hero’ like Ray Lewis is.

Comment by wbb 01.31.13 @ 11:16 am

Ray Lewis is trash. One more week of his ass crack on TV. He hasn’t been the best player on that Defense for 10 years.

Comment by Upittbaseball 01.31.13 @ 11:21 am

Nerlins Noel (sp?) a rejection machine!!

Comment by Dan 01.31.13 @ 11:48 am

1. Ole Miss has yet to play a team ranked in the Top 25 RPI, and are 1 and 3 aginst teams ranked 26 thru 50.

2. Ray Lewis has a tattoo of Ray Lewis … ’nuff said

Comment by wbb 01.31.13 @ 1:10 pm

@wbb, not questioning that at all. Kentucky did take it to them, and Florida may just as well.

My point was only that, if you win, they will come!!

Which can then be used to further the point, if Ole Miss goes on an 8 game losing streak, the gym will only be half full at the end of the year.

Win Coach Chryst Win!!!

By the way, when is signing day. I thought it was next week, then someone on here said Saturday??? Usually during the week, don’t remember one on the weekend.

Comment by Dan 01.31.13 @ 2:23 pm

Tomorrow (Friday) is Marino’s wedding anniversary too. Ouch…

Comment by Jackagain 01.31.13 @ 3:59 pm

Next year’s schedule is really good – if they are competitive the future can only bring in better talent – and hopefully more people will pack HF!

Comment by markp 01.31.13 @ 4:05 pm

signing day is next Wednesday Feb 6

Pitt was averaging close to 54k during the last couple years of Wannstedt’s reign, and that was with a BE schedule. I agree if they start winning 9 or more games a year especially with more big names, we may reach close to 60k

Comment by wbb 01.31.13 @ 4:11 pm

LOI Signing Day is Wed. Feb. 6th.

Comment by Dr. Tom 01.31.13 @ 5:45 pm

Oops, sorry for the redundancy, didn’t refresh my screen prior to the last post.

Comment by Dr. Tom 01.31.13 @ 5:46 pm

LMAO Emel… absolutely!

The comments by PC’s brother were pretty insightful (link above from Trib) in a lot of ways and confirms what folks were saying throughout the day… what is most striking is his view that this is a MATCH of man and institution and city!

Comment by PittScript 01.31.13 @ 6:36 pm

Powered by WordPress © PittBlather.com