You can almost feel the trepidation in the words. The hesitation to publish. The dread at what may come from it. Yet it happened and it must be reported: Chad Voytik had a very good practice.
In his best practice since coming to Pitt this summer, the freshman quarterback showed almost all of the tools that drew the reviews of national scouting evaluators, enticed the last coaching staff, made the current staff want to keep him in the recruiting class, and had Pitt fans excited.
On display Monday night was an impressive combination of pocket presence, arm strength, accuracy, speed, downfield awareness while rolling out, and an ability to throw on the run. And the key word there was the adjective:
Impressive.
Oh, god…
THATSIT!!!!!!!!!!!THATSWHATWEVEBEENWAITINGFOR!!ITELLYOUTINOISDONEITSVOYTIKTIMEBABEEEE!!!!!OMGZOMGSTARTHIMNOWPUTTINO ONTHEBENCHTHISISWHATTHETEAMNEEDSCANNOTWALLOWINMEDIOCRITYANYLONGER!!CHRYSTISTHEMANANDHEKNOWSTHATHE CANTPLAYTINOIFHEWANTSTHISTEAMTOHAVEANYCHANCEBUTIFHEDOESYOUCANBETITISBECAUSEOFTHESUNSERINAMEORTHECENTRALCATHOLICMAFIAORSOMEOTHERNEBULOUSREASONTHATHASTINOSTILLSTARTINGOTHERTHAN HEISTHEBESTOPTIONBYNOWTHREEDIFFERENTCOACHINGSTAFFSWITHDIFFERENTOFFENSIVESTYLESTOWARDSQUARTERBACKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Okay. Is that out of the system?
It’s true, Voytik had a very good day. Confirmed by others.
Freshman quarterback Chad Voytik looked like a different player Monday night, compared to the first days of training camp.
Now before Pitt fans start jumping to conclusions and looking for Voytik in the starting lineup Sept. 1 against Youngstown State, I’ll say this: Relax.
Voytik isn’t ready to take over for fifth-year senior Tino Sunseri. He missed spring practice because he was still in high school, and he is not accustomed to playing under center, a fundamental element of Chryst’s offense, although he does use the shotgun at times.
But Voytik looked supremely poised and comfortable in the pocket when Pitt wrapped up the last of its two-a-day practices in the indoor facility on the South Side.
…
Voytik hit wide receiver Cam Saddler with a perfectly placed pass in the near corner of the end zone and later found freshman tight end J.P. Holtz for a score. A few plays previous, Holtz made a nice catch across the middle when he tipped a Voytik pass to himself while falling to the turf.
It’s also worth noting that in the morning practice he had a bad enough practice that he even took to twitter to vent.
Bad practice this morning. Only good thing is we have another one later to make up for it.
#frustrated— Chad Voytik (@Voytik_8) August 20, 2012
So, one practice bad, the next really good. Is there anything else to take away from this?
ZOMG!!!!!!!YOUJUSTDONTGETIT!!!VOYTIKISTHEMANALEADERHEHADABADPRACTICEANDRESPONDEDTURNEDITAROUND!!!!HESALREADYMOREOFAMANTHANTINOISHISTEAMMATESALREADYLIKEHIMMORETHANTINOHEHASTOBETHESTARTERICANTTAKEWATCHINGTINY–SEEWHATIDIDTHEREITSFUNNYBECAUSEOFHISSIZEANDARMSTRENGTHANDTHEWAYHESHRINKSINTHEGAME–ITISOOBVIOUSANDANYONEWHODISAGREESCLEARLYHASSUCHLOWEXPECTATIONSANDISNTATRUEFANOFPITT!!!!!!!!!!!!
Er, right.
It is encouraging. It is progress. But, progress is not a straight line progression. Step forwards. Step backs.
Not a lot of time for any more real movements in the two deep I think so what we see over the next few days is probably, with exception of injured kids returning to play, what we will see next Saturday.
On Friday after camp ends I’ll post up a couple of predictions threads, one for the team in general and one for players, for us guys to weigh in with our opinions on.
I think its been a great training camp and its been fun as hell to watch the scrimmages. I always like it when players come out of nowhere to do well like Jack Lippert and Donald Ezell have done or when a new guy impresses enough to win a spot on the two deep like Crockett, Vinopal and Bisnowaty have.
Plus seeing guys that you just know will be there for us in the future even if they don’t play much during the season. Shell may be one of those, Chris Wuestner has opened eyes, Voytik and Jason Frimpong are two also.
We have talent on this team. There is no doubt about that and we’ll win some ballgames, perhaps a lot if the injury gods overlook us and the ball bounces our way sometimes.
Any possibility of a scouting report on Youngstown leading up to the game?
Rumors abound that YSU has more talent than usual this year and are coming in with an attitude.
By the end of the season, Marino was the starter and played the entire game. Pitt went 11-1 that year.
Albeit Voytik is no Marino… I hope Chryst uses him during the season… no need to red shirt Voytik.
I don’t recall Bill Stull ever being as wretchedly bad as Tino Sunseri is on his normal game days.
Go back and watch the end of the Backyard Brawl of 2010 (if you can stand watching those awful Urban Combat uniforms…), or the overtime of the Utah game — both under Wanny’s system (which they say fits Tino’s “skill set”). Or watch the 4th Qtrs of last year’s Iowa, ND, Cincy, or WVU games. Watch Tino in the Pitt (errr, BVB Compass or whatever it’s called…) Bowl.
Common theme: pressure! Under game (or defense) pressure, Tino folds like a cheap suit. Takes stupid sacks at the worst possible times (and then doesn’t have the courage to stand up and say “That one’s on me, I shouldda gotten rid of the ball.”). Or he uses his short stature and weak scatter-arm to (over)(under) throw too far (behind)(ahead) of his WRs. I could go on and on.
Point being, what is to be gained by playing Tino again? We’ve seen this movie, and we know how it ends. Tino the Magnificent is why I didn’t renew my season tix, I just can’t justify spending that much money to watch that guy play even one more time.
Even with this year’s relatively easy schedule (compared to next year…), I can’t see Tino doing any better than 7-5, with 6-6 being more likely, and another trip to Birmingham, big whoop.
PLEASE play ABT this year (and probably still go 6-6 and traipse off to Birmingham in January) to get somebody ready for next year.
HTP
Rivals (pantherlair) has a pretty good depth chart but it is not the “official” depth chart but based upon his observations and some conversations with coaches.. He started the depth chart after spring ball and revised it since.
I’m in favor of sitting Voytik. For ever Teddy Bridgewater, how many Pat Bostics are there? Guys that had potential that were thrown into the fire before they were ready and never were able to realize that potential…
If they go 6-6 this year will be a huge disappointment. I’ll take 7-5 and a bowl win as something to build on. I think 8-3 + a bowl win is also within reach, if things break our way.
1. The last game we saw of Stull at that was the Sun Bowl. ’nuff said.
2. It was reported that Sunseri was a star during the spring and preseason practices. We now realize the problem with that report…
I’m no Sunseri fan, and I certainly don’t trust him in a late game situation, but Pitt did win 7 games with him in 2010 (I’m not counting the bowl).
And, as I’ve repeated numerous times, give last year’s team this season’s schedule and they win 8 games, even with Tino as the QB.
Tino may be a lot of the reason Pitt doesn’t win 10+ games this season, but he won’t be the reason Pitt fails to 8+.
Face it, there’s no reliable option right now behind him. Anderson apparently has a chronic injury issue. Voytik is a true freshman. Jones and Gonzalez aren’t viable.
I did find Chryst’s tirade at Tino to be rather encouraging.
Tino is going to start because he is the best Chryst has and he knows it. All Chryst can do is play to his strengths while limiting situations where he breaks down.
I say it is not a bad thing for Tino to go into the season as #2. It will accelerate his development. As to whether he will be ready to come in, that is another matter. I still think Trey has to get healthy and be the number two.
Chryst should get him playing time starting in game 1 even if for 1 series… and build from there as the season goes on. I’m not saying he should start… but should see playing time every game.
Therefore next year, there will be a real battle for starting QB between Voytik and Savage… and can’t use the excuse of game day experience. The backup, whoever it is, will be a solid backup.
In my opinion there isn’t a reason to start Voytik now because I don’t think he’s a better QB than Sunseri at this point. Mid-year, who knows. That is why I say if you don’t lock a redshirt on Voytik then get him as involved as possible so he’s a true and viable option if they yank Sunseri or if he gets hurt.
Now – I’ll say this also. I agree with you (Ghost40 BTW) that CV may be that playmaker/gamer type QB that every team wants. He’s exciting to watch out there and you can really see his potential. He looked different from scrimmage #1 to scrimmage #2 and even better two days later apparently.
I never got that feeling with Sunseri at all since he was recruited. My hopes for him were that he’d fill the bill as a game manager, decent passer type QB. I’m not a big Sunseri fan and was calling for him to be replaced last season. I’m also not a big Voytik critic in that I think he’s a good football player.
I just look at the expectations PITT fans have even now for Voytik and try to temper those with what I see is the reality of the staff’s choice of QB to be a starter this season. Plus, I’ve seen a lot of true FR QBs thrown into action then never being heard from again. We saw it with Pat Bostick also.
I’d hate to have that happen with Voytik if this isn’t done correctly.
Naming a FR QB2 and having him take game prep practice snaps is 100% better than having to throw a kid in without preparation. I think this staff understands that and it would be interesting to know if Anderson’s injury allowed that move to #2 to happen or if the staff was going to fleet up Voytik anyway that early. Regardless, the fact that he’s playing as 2nd string (probably) and getting a lot of camp reps going into the season is the best way to prepare him for action.
There is no way Chryst will play someone that doesnt put the team in the best position to win. If that is Tiny, then so be it. Voytik, fine. I am sure he also will not stick with a lsing proposition very long either.
Anderson should be the emergency #3.
I’m not sure Bostic is a good example.
If I recall, he had problems at summer camp… homesick or something… and went home for a few weeks. Almost quit altogether before the season started. Wanny had to talk him back to camp.
Bostic didn’t have the fire in the belly that Voytik has… Voytik is a hard worker.
By the way, Russell Wilson, like Tino, had multiple coaches and ‘systems’ between his times at NCState and then Wisconsin…in fact, moved to a state he had apparently zero connection to — and still put up Heisman caliber numbers last year…and we never once heard him whine about a new system or coordinator, did we?
Here is the bottom line for PITT this year – it has to go 7-5 at least and have no outside the lines problems. Job #1 for Paul Chryst is to bring a full year of stability back to the program and win more games than he loses..
That means not playing Voytik to “get him ready” for the ACC, as so many PITT fans have stated they want to see happen, if Voytik isn’t the best QB to get us wins this year. Voytik is not the most important player on this team and the team does not revolve around Voytik.
He has a great shot to be a starting QB at PITT but other players will have a say in how well that turns out. Savage, Anderson and Chapman will try to do the same thing Voytik is doing this season – working his ass off for playing time.
If PITT fans are pointing to Voytik as playing when he’s a true FR you can be sure they will do the same thing with Tra’von Chapman next year, especially since it seems like Chapman is trying to get here in the spring.
If you look at all four recruiting sites and the averages of where both Chapman and Voytik were ranked nationally as QBs you get Voytik at 13th and Chapman at 15th. Not a lot of difference there. Nothing is guaranteed for Chad Voytik when it comes to being a starting QB at PITT, but getting PT would be a great help for him down the road.
Watching him struggle like last year should not be an option.
Voytek needs to get a series or two with the first unit every game, not on an if we can get him in situation, especially against powerhouses likes YSU. I don’t care if they are better than normal.
As an analogy, Wanny was a big time winner and point preventer at Ok St, the U, and USC. And like it or not, he was still the best head coach the Dolphins has had since Marino left.
1) Will Tino play every down this year?
No
2) Can Trey Anderson be counted on to be ready to go when called?
Apparently not
3) Will Chad Voytik be redshirted?
You’ve got to be kidding
FTR, although Voytik and Chapman share similar ratings, they are completely different style of QB. Similar HS systems but different strengths (from what appears to be).
Anyone under center needs the line to perform well, stay healthy and be consistent. That is the foundation (for me) of wins this year.
I’m (hoping for) looking at a 8 win season as the measure for success…AND as you mentioned – stability.
HTP
Will the athletic department be doing anything to get people excited/encourage attendance at the game? Are there any pep rallies for students or fan nights before the season starts?
I know they’ve done a great job online, but are they doing anything on campus?
I still maintain with Wanny as DC and Walt as OC, Pitt could have been dynamite this past decade…oh well. We’ll see what kind of HC Chryst is but I get the feeling he’s gonna be good.
Give the kid a chance to catch his breath and move into the dorm at least before you anoint him as Pitt’s starting QB for God’s sake.
When I was a Pitt freshman, I didn’t even know where all the good bars were yet two weeks into the semester. It takes time, its a process. I’ve heard that stated before by someone in the know.
http://whyfordesign.com/pittfootballcountdown.html
Courtesy of me.
S. Oakland – Calicos, S.O.D(Now Bootleggers), Mad Mex
Campus – Peters Place, Zelda’s CJ’s, The Attic, Hemingways.
N. Oakland – Mitchell’s, Luna, Chiefs!!!
Oh, the good ole days!!!
Coach’ll show ‘em.
Ray Graham to be interviewed later.
A
And that his 4 star ratings had to be in error as well. Well maybe that was incorrect too !
How about that… he can throw off the run, who would have thunk it. Even Marino wasn’t too good outside the pocket. Maybe if Chad got more 1rst team reps it would speed up his progress, ya think.
Well it not’s going to happen as long as Sir Tino is on the team. As we all know, even he can talk back to the coaches(apparently he already has to PC), get away with it(more than several times), and never a thought of benching is discussed. We already got the “Tino has had 3 OC’s swan song poor kid article” from Zeise before he left. So we’re all prepped for another mediocre season with excuses built in already. And now we’re hearing Youngstown State is a lot better than normal, so that when we’re only up 10-3 at halftime or 7-0, well u know. The Penguins are better than normal and this is a new offensive system. And oh my it’s his 3rd OC in 3 years.
But as Matt N. said :
By the way, Russell Wilson, like Tino, had multiple coaches and ‘systems’ between his times at NCState and then Wisconsin…in fact, moved to a state he had apparently zero connection to — and still put up Heisman caliber numbers last year…and we never once heard him whine about a new system or coordinator, did we?
Comment by Matt N. 08.21.12 @ 2:01 pm
The big difference here being…. Russell Wilson actually has talent !
Check out the “Herbie Awards”… interesting list..
The only positive is….PITT fans are now quite knowledgeable of and can find their way around Birmingham, Alabama quite well.
But hey, you know who, gives us OUR BEST CHANCE to get back to the infamous and more than likely future to be, defunct BBVA GyroCompass Whatever Bowl !! (who knows maybe lightning will strike and we’ll end up in St. Petersburg for whatever that Bowl is called this year)
Veritas et Virtus
Yet he performed very good and led PITT to 10 points in the 4rth quarter, and those 10 points turned out to be the decisive points in the close win against Maine. After Sunseri threw 2 picks in the 3rd quarter.
He was thrown back out there again, on the road in a hostile environment, against Rutgers after Sunseri flopped yet again, yet there was no consideration given that Anderson was a true freshmen walk-on playing in his 2nd quarter of action and 1rst quarter of action against a D1 team. Only that he was not a D1 QB and he was even smaller than Sunseri. Same thing against Utah on a very windy day at Heinz after another Sunseri flop of a performance.
Strange how these considerations are given to some but not to others, isn’t it ?
Sam Werner reporting that CV looked good for a second practice in a row….
Now I’m not going to be in the camp that says start CV right away. BUT, I would LOVE to see him continue to improve until he gets to the point that PC just has to get him on the field. Keep up the stellar play, become more consistent, know the playbook, and have the game slow down. Then CV can start to push Tino for playing time.
If nothing else, I hope this is a good sign for what CV can do for us in the future.
11 days left, just can’t wait!!!
OK, I can dream can’t I??
Then there is the loose-loose one where Tino gets hurt early season and somebody gets thrown out there to do their best. If it’s CV and he’s not ready it could leave a lasting mark on his development.
Somewhere in the middle would be Tino pulls the same old under achievement routine and by the end of the season after Voytik has seen the field a few times, Chyrst is fed up enough with Tino Time that Voytik gets the nod to start.
I hate to admit it, but it just doesn’t make any sense to unseat a fifth year senior with two years experience under his belt if he can at least play AVERAGE. So get used to the idea, unless Sunseri really, really stinks out the place, that it’s going to be “Tino Time” for another season.
Obviously, and if you read any other media writers on PITT, Voytik has shown a lot different play now than he was then.
Regarding Anderson’s playing as a true freshman; no PITT fan ever saw Anderson as being a future starting QB for PITT. The feelings about Voytik are obviously different, especially given the circumstance that surrounded the 2007 season and Pat Bostick. We look at Voytik as being a possible multi-year starter at PITT.
Joe D – you are off base with your low opinion of Pat Bostick’s desire for competition. He was a huge competitor and was 100% dedicated to PITT football. Also, DW never had to ‘talk him into’ returning to camp, that wasn’t the problem at all.
So my take on the current QB situation is that either you go all in with either Sunseri or Voytik. If you are committed to Sunseri, then you redshirt Voytik unless Sunseri is injured. I don’t think you burn a year of Voytik’s eligibility, if you are only going to play him in mop up duty. Reps in practice will be more important to his development than a few plays in blow out games.
On the other hand, if you aren’t sold on Sunseri and you don’t think he will be the starter the whole year then play Voytik. The offense is already going to be run heavy, so Voytik won’t be asked to do much.
I think the amount of criticism on Sunseri is becoming a bit much. I know I’ve been critical of him and he struggled last year at times. BUT he was 3 plays away from being the QB of a 9 win Big East Champion Pitt team that just installed a vastly different offense that was not changed at all based on the team. And if the Pitt D could have stopped a 1 man UConn team in 2010 then Sunseri would have been the QB of the sole Big East Champion Pitt team. My point is that he isn’t the worst QB ever like some people like to think.
That being said, I’m not really sure which route to go in Sunseri vs. Voytik. I guess that’s why I’m sitting in an office and not a football coach.
and while we are talking about bars, gotta give zeldas some props, many hookups started there and ended up in tower c. including the ultimate hookup in which i met the wife.
i love that we have a community on fans that are so passionate and dedicated to pitt! if any of you travel, lets arrange for some tailgating down here in acc country next year, cause i’ll be first in line for any tickets in the nc area.
I stand by my opinion of Bostick compared to Voytik… they are apples and oranges…
Voytik has fire in the belly and is a competitor..
Voytik is more mature and can handle playing time as a frosh and I doubt that will affect his development or mental aspect of his game. Just give him a little play time EVERY game…
Optimum, my cable provider, doesn’t offer ESPN3. Will Direct/Dish TV cover the YSU game so I can catch it at a bar?
When Luna’s would get raided for underage drinking, Larry had a trap door behind the bar and would usher each of us out quickly with a bottle of beer in hand!
Picture was fantastic (also depends on your computer) and no charge.
Only problem, sitting at a desk chair to watch, after awhile just not as comfortable as watching in a recliner or on the couch watching your tv.
If you’re in a pinch though, was pretty good.
I loved both his meatball subs and his meatball bowl (meatballs w/sauce over melted mozzarella) served with a piece of italian bread on the side. i can still taste it!! It was great washed down with those Budweiser long necks he served.
One night I had some fratboy in a coat and tie (and obviously “tripping” in a bad way on some halucinogenic) leap on my back while letting out blood curdling screams while I was standing at the counter just inside Quinque’s front door. I flipped him onto the floor, he got up, eyes rolling and uttering incoherent noises, and bolted out the door. Scared the heck out of me and I wound up staying for several unplanned additional beers to calm the frayed nerves!!
I remember having this one chick in there convinced I was a foreign exchange student from France. And you know the French are supposed to be great lovers. You should have heard my French accent that night, lol
Needless to say the night ended at her place in the Quad.
Those were the days, every night a different bar and a different girl !!


