masthead.jpg

switchconcepts.com, U3dpdGNo-a25, DIRECT rubiconproject.com, 14766, RESELLER pubmatic.com, 30666, RESELLER, 5d62403b186f2ace appnexus.com, 1117, RESELLER thetradedesk.com, switchconcepts, RESELLER taboola.com, switchconceptopenrtb, RESELLER bidswitch.com, switchconcepts, RESELLER contextweb.com, 560031, RESELLER amazon-adsystem.com, 3160, RESELLER crimtan.com, switch, RESELLER quantcast.com, switchconcepts , RESELLER rhythmone.com, 1934627955, RESELLER ssphwy.com, switchconcepts, RESELLER emxdgt.com, 59, RESELLER appnexus.com, 1356, RESELLER sovrn.com, 96786, RESELLER, fafdf38b16bf6b2b indexexchange.com, 180008, RESELLER nativeads.com, 52853, RESELLER theagency.com, 1058, RESELLER google.com, pub-3515913239267445, DIRECT, f08c47fec0942fa0
November 9, 2007

I freely concede my bias against Defensive Coordinator Paul Rhoads. He has been defensive coordinator for too long and had too many games where he has shown his deficiencies. His defensive schemes, teachings, approach and inability to comprehend any way to defend the spread offense and/or mobile QBs have been consistent through two head coaches. Three games where the defense has played average or better hardly erases that and does not begin to convince me that he has “turned the corner” or had the “light go on.”
What does he have going for him? Players love him and he’s enthusiastic.

“As the season has gone on, I’ve realized, like my dad said, that you never really stop learning,” he said. “One thing I did was make a conscious effort after the Navy game to coach and teach more positive throughout the week, and the team has benefited by that.

“And as a coach, you want to make sure the kids have the right mind-set. I believe that is one thing we’ve done to positively affect their mind-set going into these last three football games.”

Here’s a truth about Paul Rhoads from the years of blogging this team. When things are going bad, you can not locate a quote, comment or interview by the guy about the problems. He just is not to be found. When things are working, though, and he looks even passably competent he’s happy to be quoted and puffed.

So, as the Pitt defense has played reasonably well in the past three games, is it any shock that he’s ready for some attention?

Personally, I saw very little that was impressive in the Syracuse game. The Orange had a 3d stringer and a freshman punt returner trying to run the ball behind a poor O-line. They had a QB play with a cracked rib in the first half and an inexperienced back-up in the second half throw for nearly 200 yards. It still nearly came undone.

Head Coach Dave Wannstedt insists he has no doubt about Rhoads as a coach. Isn’t that great?

The thing that is bothersome is that Rhoads and Wannstedt are happy to insist that it is the coaching that has led to the improvements the past three games. Yet, there was no accountability for last season (or any other). Apparently the Navy game, the UConn or Virginia game weren’t his fault either. Guess that wasn’t the coaching but on the players.

Although the defense has responded for the past three games, Rhoads, who is in his eighth season as the Panthers’ defensive coordinator, still has a legion of critics who think it is time for head coach Dave Wannstedt to find another coordinator.

They cite the Panthers’ struggles on defense in the past few years and last year’s collapse — the team lost its final five games and gave up 1,621 yards of offense and 139 points in the final three — as well as this year’s struggles as evidence his system is not working.

But Wannstedt doesn’t see it that way. He concurs that the defense has played well in the three games since the Navy debacle. He talks about the defense’s lofty rankings in certain categories: The Panthers are 17th in NCAA Division I-A in total defense and 13th in pass defense.

Really, that opening article was just warm-up for spit takes.

And he is puzzled by popular criticism that his defensive schemes and game plans are passive, and that he does not coach an aggressive style of defense. He believes aggressiveness is critical, but frequent blitzing is not the only way to play aggressive defense.

“I believe in aggressiveness and I have always coached aggressiveness,” Rhoads said. “I have never put numbers out there on the table publicly, but I can tell you, if you break down my eight years at Pitt, I can certainly point to a lot higher numbers of games lost that we blitzed more than normal and a lot more games that we won that we blitzed less than normal, but the perception is that wasn’t the case. People seem to think we only blitz in wins, but that’s not at all accurate.

“And aggressive football and attacking football can be played with a four-man rush because those things are based on how well, as I like to say, your players are going north in attacking an offense. And it really has to do with how fast your team plays, and that comes from how confident they are.”

I really feared my head would explode as I read and re-read that. Rhoads hallmark has been the bend-but-don’t-break defense. A read-and-react approach. Don’t give up the big play. In fact, until this season

Nevertheless, Rhoads is preaching for his linebackers to be more aggressive instead of reading and reacting to plays.

Now why would people think his defensive schemes were passive?

Wait. Let’s start with the last statement in the block quote: “And it really has to do with how fast your team plays, and that comes from how confident they are.

I would have thought it comes from the player’s ability and how well they are positioned, coached and taught. No. Apparently they just need to have confidence. Self-esteem was the key all along. In the Navy game, they just didn’t feel good about things.
For the record, I don’t care that much about blitzing. It’s an essential component, but it isn’t the end-all, be-all of a defense. I do want to see pressure up front, and blitzing is also a reward for the D-line to really attack. It seems, though, that Rhoads is just indicting his past performance as a DC. The team has tried to blitz, but failed to produce the pressure. They couldn’t generate any pass rush or pressure up front. Not a shock for anyone who has watched this team the past few years, but just a reminder.

Although the Panthers are not blitzing more this season, Rhoads said they made some minor changes to the scheme in the offseason that have paid off. Some of the changes involve mixing up and disguising coverages, but the most important change is that the Panthers have pulled a safety up closer to the line of scrimmage to be more involved in stopping the run — they have gone from a seven-man front to an eight-man front — and it has paid off.

And this is something I have to give credit — to Coach Wannstedt. It’s about the only thing he did right with Paul Rhoads. He took away his duties as the secondary coach and put him on linebackers. It meant that Rhoads was no longer dropping the safety to provide extra support against the pass, but would bring up the safeties to help the linebackers and the D-line more.

This was something that was in the works starting last spring when Rhoads took over the linebackers. Not to mention, once Rhoads had to be responsible for the Linebackers’ performance he did become a lot more interested in making sure the D-line was improving. It also took until this season before Rhoads actually thought that maybe it might help the defense if they worked as an entire defense in some practices and meetings rather than always in individual units.

Again, seven years as a DC, and it took his job being on the line and being responsible for linebackers rather than DBs for Rhoads to see the value of bringing up the safeties against the run.





Reading this makes me sick… PAUL RHOADS BLOWS… He tried to say he is aggressive??? Bend but dont break. Thats not aggressive dumbass. I hate paul rhoads so much. He is the worst DC in the big east and alot of football. FIRE HIS ASS!!!

Comment by Adam 11.09.07 @ 9:58 am

The remaining 3 games for Pitt should be the last chance for Rhoads. If it is the same story (give up 200+ yds to Ray Rice, get torched by the mobile QB’s of USF and WVU)

Comment by Chris 11.09.07 @ 9:29 am

very well written. you dont suddenly ‘turn the corner’ and ‘get it’ after 7 years of embarassing defenses. we will never compete nationally with him as the DC. FIRE PAUL RHOADES.

Comment by mat tin orlando 11.09.07 @ 10:22 am

Paul Rohoads is an ass and cannot coach, hopefully this is his last year but stranger thaings have happened!

What I worry about is dumb ass Wanny, Wanny couldn’t coach his way out of a pee wee football game.

Next year is the swan song, they will all be gone!

2008 is the year the excuses stop, I still think no bowl game no Wanny in 2008.

Nice article, Rhoads is a dumb ass, like his boss.

Comment by Stuart's alter-ego! 11.09.07 @ 10:50 am

It has taken Rhodes 7 years to figure out that disguising coverages is a good thing?!!?!?! He has the title of DC and this is a revelation to him???

We can’t wait another 7 years for him to figure out that you should develop talent and teach young players as they don’t just show up ready to play at this level.

I never want to hear the term BASE DEFENSE again for as long as I live. The name Paul Rhodes in of itself will forever equal incompetence in its truest form!

F that guy! F him in the A!

Rhoades can’t leave fast enough.

Comment by Tony In Harrisburg 11.09.07 @ 1:35 pm

From the Navy postmortem (via Post-Gazette):

Safety Mike Phillips added: “We had a great game plan, we just did not execute it as players. Coach Rhoads put together a great scheme, and if everybody does their job on every play it would be all right. But it seems on every play there are one or two guys not doing their job and that causes breakdowns.”

So lighten up guys. The DC’s schemes are fine. They only look bad because of the breakdowns that happen on every play.

Comment by Brian of Brooklyn 11.09.07 @ 6:52 pm

I jump up and down really good and I can tell my safeties to play 40 yards off the ball to guard against 80 yard passes that no college quarterbacks can throw. I can train a D with 3 NFL starters to give up 150 yards rushing to a fat bag of f*ck like DJ Hernandez whose nose didn’t even run before he played us. I will design a scheme that will give up 100 points to WVU on December 1. Can I be the next DC?

Comment by geeman2001 11.09.07 @ 9:21 pm

We are taking the wrong approach here. Rhoades is a great coach. Not only is he a great defensive coach, but he would make an excellent head coach. Someplace else!!!

Comment by TMGPanther 11.09.07 @ 9:25 pm

Well, it didn’t have 3 NFL ‘starters’ last year but still …

I’m a little alarmed that these articles couldn’t muster more than 8 posts of outrage. Rhoads truly has saved his job, and Pitt truly will blow again next year.

Comment by geeman2001 11.10.07 @ 10:20 pm

This article says it all…. Rhoads is the best friend of any struggling offense. What frightens me most is Wannstedt’s defensive philosophy is exactly the same as Rhoads. This bend but don’t break crap is a philosophy used by DC that can’t figure out how to stop the other team. Wannstedt has implemented offensive and defensive philosophies that were created for pros, but the problem is the pro caliber player at Pitt at present is far and few. We need creative coaches that design offenses and defenses for the talent available. Until Pitt turns the corner, it will never attract the type of players that Wannstedt, Rhoads, and Cavenaugh need to succeed. My suggestion, go get the best available I-AA coach. Coaches that succeed at that level learn how to recognize diamonds in the rough, and they develop offensive and defensive system that give their players the best opportunities to win. Check out Jim Tressel at Ohio State, he’s done a pretty good job after coming from I-AA Youghstown State. And look no further than WVU, Rich R. once coached at Salem College, and created offenses and defenses that have faired fairly well at the major college level. Pitt needs to get with the program and go get a head coach that knows how to win with subpar talent. Heck, I don’t even think we have subpar talent; I believe we just need a coaching staff that’s smart enough to devise ways to give our kids an opportunity to succeed. Sad to say, this coaching staff is set in their ways, and you can’t teach these old dogs new tricks. These good old boys actually believe they got all the answers. What will their excuses be after we get thumped the next three games. I love Pitt, but the best thing that could happen to the program is to lose the final three games. Maybe, just maybe, someone will wake up in the athletic dept. and realize this crew must go. In case they haven’t noticed, the fans are beginning to bend and break to the stadium gates.

Comment by L. Cole 11.11.07 @ 1:34 am

Powered by WordPress © PittBlather.com

Site Meter